Lesson 9: Exchange rate systems, shocks and policy
Evaluate responses to a lost export market
SkillsExchange rate systems and effectsResponding to unseen stimulus
Worked example
In 2020 China imposed duties of 80.5% on Australian barley, which the Australian Government said blocked almost $1 billion a year of sales (Minister for Foreign Affairs, 4 August 2023). Two responses were possible: (A) pay ongoing subsidies to barley growers to make up their lost income, or (B) challenge the duties at the World Trade Organization while helping exporters find other markets.
Evaluate which response better served the Australian economy, using the criterion of efficiency.
Step 1: Define the criterion
Allocative efficiency: resources go to their most valued uses. Dynamic efficiency: firms innovate and adapt over time.
Step 2: Analyse response A
Ongoing subsidies keep growers producing for a market that no longer pays, at taxpayers' expense. They protect incomes and jobs in grain regions in the short run but blunt the price signal to switch crops or buyers: low allocative efficiency, and they reduce the pressure to adapt (dynamic efficiency).
Step 3: Analyse response B
Diversification moves barley to the buyers who value it most (Saudi Arabia, Japan, South-East Asia), at some cost in lower prices at first. It keeps resources responding to world prices and builds new market relationships: higher allocative and dynamic efficiency. The WTO case keeps pressure on the trading partner without distorting Australian production.
Step 4: Use the outcome as evidence
China removed the duties from 5 August 2023 after Australia paused its WTO case (April 2023) in return for an expedited review by China; in the meantime growers had sold much of their crop to other markets.
Step 5: Decide
Against the efficiency criterion, response B was better: it let prices guide resources and made the industry less dependent on one buyer, while subsidies would have locked resources into a closed market. A limit: diversified markets may pay lower prices, and the adjustment costs fall on growers.
Answer
Response B better served the economy on efficiency grounds: diversification and a WTO challenge kept barley flowing to the buyers who valued it most and reduced dependence on one market (allocative and dynamic efficiency), whereas ongoing subsidies would have held resources in a market that had closed, at taxpayers' cost. The duties were removed from 5 August 2023.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Define the criterion precisely.
Analyse each option against it, with evidence.
Weigh the options from more than one perspective and make a decision.
State a limit or condition on the decision.
Watch out for
Deciding without a criterion, or naming one and never applying it.
Considering only one perspective (growers) and not taxpayers, consumers or the wider economy.