Lesson 5: The tariff diagram and its calculations
Who gains and who loses from a tariff, in dollars
SkillTariff diagrams and calculations
Worked example
In an illustrative market, and (Q in thousand tonnes, P in $ per tonne). The world price is $30 a tonne and the government imposes a tariff of $10 a tonne.
Calculate the change in consumer surplus, the change in producer surplus, the tariff revenue and the welfare loss, and show that they balance.
Step 1: Quantities at the world price
; ; imports 100 thousand tonnes.
Step 2: Quantities at $40
; ; imports 50 thousand tonnes.
Step 3: Consumer surplus falls
The trapezium between the price lines left of demand: .
Consumers pay $10 more on the 120 they still buy and lose the surplus on the 20 they stop buying.
Step 4: Producer surplus rises
The trapezium between the price lines left of supply: .
Step 5: Revenue and the triangles
Revenue . Production loss ; consumption loss ; welfare loss .
Step 6: Check the balance
Consumers' loss producers' gain revenue welfare loss . ✓ All in $ thousand.
Answer
Consumer surplus −$1.3 million, producer surplus +$550 000, revenue $500 000, welfare loss $250 000 (production loss $150 000, consumption loss $100 000).
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Illustrative market. Quantities in thousand tonnes.
Method
Find , at and , at .
ΔCS = −t × (Q₂ + Q₄)/2; ΔPS = t × (Q₁ + Q₃)/2.
Revenue = t(Q₄ − Q₃); each triangle = ½ × t × the change in quantity.
Check: consumer loss = producer gain + revenue + welfare loss.
Watch out for
Treating the revenue as part of the welfare loss.
Using rectangles instead of trapeziums for the changes in surplus.