Lesson 9: Trading blocs, their outcomes for Australia, and the IA2 investigation
Planning an IA2 investigation: choosing criteria
SkillsEvaluating trading blocsArguing protection and free trade
Worked example
Your IA2 task asks you to recommend whether the Australian Government should ratify the Australia–EU Free Trade Agreement concluded in March 2026. Choose up to three economic criteria, say what evidence you would use for each, and write the decision sentence of your introduction.
Step 1: Read the purpose
The decision is "ratify or not", so every criterion must be one on which the agreement could make Australia better or worse off.
Step 2: Choose measurable criteria
(1) Economic growth: change in export values and output in the industries that gain access (beef, sheep meat, dairy, grains, critical minerals). (2) Living standards: prices of EU imports (the agreement removes Australia's remaining tariffs on most EU goods) and jobs. (3) Resource allocation: whether resources move to Australia's comparative advantage, and the adjustment costs for industries facing EU competition.
Three criteria the data can measure are better than many vague ones; QCAA allows no more than three.
Step 3: Plan the evidence
DFAT's A-EU FTA outcomes (duty-free entry for 97.8% of current exports on entry into force; beef and sheep meat quotas), ABS trade data by partner and commodity (2025 exports to the EU $25.9 billion, imports $84.8 billion), the Productivity Commission's work on trade agreements, and views from farm groups and import-competing manufacturers.
Step 4: Plan the analysis and counter-argument
Use a tariff diagram for an EU-protected product to show the gain to Australian exporters, discuss trade creation and diversion, and answer the strongest objection (for example, that the beef quotas are small relative to the EU market, or that geographical-indication rules restrict some Australian product names).
Step 5: Write the decision sentence
"This report recommends that Australia ratify the A-EU FTA because, judged on economic growth, living standards and resource allocation, its gains to exporters and consumers outweigh its adjustment costs, provided the beef and sheep meat quotas are filled."
Answer
Criteria: economic growth, living standards and resource allocation, each tied to measurable evidence (export values, import prices and jobs, resource movement and adjustment costs); the introduction states the decision and its condition.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Start from the purpose and the decision it asks for.
Choose at most three criteria the data can measure.
Match each criterion to current, sourced evidence and plan the counter-argument.
State the decision in the introduction.