Lesson 1: Market concentration: market power and efficiency
Market concentration: the cost of a dominant firm's price
SkillMarket concentration: power and efficiency
Worked example
In an illustrative market, demand is (price in dollars, in units a week) and every unit costs $20 to produce (marginal cost). Under competition the price would be $20. A dominant firm sets the price at $60 instead.
(a) Find the quantity sold at each price. (b) Calculate consumer surplus at each price, the dominant firm's profit at $60 and the deadweight loss. (c) Explain what the result shows about allocative efficiency.
Step 1: Find the competitive quantity
At : , so and units.
Step 2: Find the quantity at $60
At : , so units.
Step 3: Consumer surplus at each price
Consumer surplus is the triangle under demand and above the price. Demand meets the price axis at $100. At $20: . At $60: .
The triangle's base is the quantity bought and its height is the gap between the highest price anyone would pay ($100) and the price charged.
Step 4: The firm's profit at $60
Profit per unit is on 400 units: a week.
Step 5: The deadweight loss
The units from 400 to 800 are no longer produced. Each was worth more to a buyer than its $20 cost. The triangle: .
Check: the $32 000 of consumer surplus under competition is now split into $8000 for consumers, $16 000 of profit and $8000 that nobody gets.
Step 6: Explain the efficiency result
Under competition price equals marginal cost, so every unit worth at least its cost is made: allocative efficiency. At $60 the price is three times marginal cost, output is halved, $16 000 of consumer surplus becomes profit, and $8000 of value a week is lost to society: the market is allocatively inefficient.
Answer
(a) 800 units at $20; 400 units at $60. (b) Consumer surplus $32 000 at $20 and $8000 at $60; profit $16 000; deadweight loss $8000 a week. (c) Pricing above marginal cost restricts output below the allocatively efficient level and destroys value.
Method
Find each quantity from the demand curve.
Consumer surplus: half × quantity × (choke price − price).
Profit: (price − marginal cost) × quantity.
Deadweight loss: half × lost output × (price − marginal cost).
Watch out for
Counting the whole fall in consumer surplus as lost value: most of it is a transfer to the firm.
Saying the firm "produces more to earn more": it earns more by producing less.