Lesson 4: Market concentration: the ACCC, the courts and competition policy
Market concentration: evaluating divestiture for supermarkets
SkillMarket concentration: the ACCC and policy
Worked example
Source 1. In 2022–23 Woolworths had 38% and Coles 29% of supermarket sales (ACCC, 2025). They held 88% of supermarkets larger than 2,000 m².
Source 2. The ACCC found Coles and Woolworths have "limited incentive to compete vigorously with each other on price", that ALDI is "an important source of price constraint", and that both chains have monopsony power with many fresh produce suppliers. It did not recommend breaking them up.
Source 3. A farmers' group argues the chains should be forced to sell stores so that growers have more buyers.
Evaluate the proposal to give the courts power to force the largest supermarkets to sell some stores, using allocative efficiency as your criterion. Plan a full response.
Step 1: State the criterion and the issue
Criterion: allocative efficiency, whether prices are close to marginal cost and output matches what consumers and suppliers value. Issue: a tight oligopoly (, 2022–23) with weak price rivalry and monopsony power over suppliers.
Step 2: Analyse how divestiture would work
Selling stores, especially the large ones (88% of supermarkets over 2,000 m² are Coles or Woolworths), to new owners would create rivals with full ranges. More sellers raise the pressure to cut prices towards cost, and more buyers of fresh produce reduce monopsony power, so growers' prices and supply rise.
Link the policy to concentration, then to conduct, then to price and output: that chain is the analysis.
Step 3: Weigh the costs
Smaller chains may lose economies of scale in buying and distribution, raising costs per unit (productive efficiency), which could offset lower margins. Divestiture is slow, legally complex and costly, and buyers for the stores may be hard to find. ALDI already constrains prices on the products it sells.
Step 4: Consider perspectives
Consumers gain if prices fall; growers (Source 3) gain bargaining power; shareholders, including super funds, lose value; the ACCC judged the measure unnecessary given its other 20 recommendations and new merger laws.
Step 5: Decide and justify
Judgement: on allocative efficiency, divestiture could help, but its benefit is uncertain while its costs are large and immediate. Stronger merger control, the mandatory grocery code and planning changes that let rivals open large stores target the same problem at lower cost, so the proposal is not justified now; it should remain a backstop if those measures fail to lower margins.
Answer
A strong response states the criterion, uses the data (CR₂ 67%, 88% of large stores), explains how divestiture would change prices and supplier bargaining, weighs lost economies of scale and legal cost, presents at least two perspectives, and makes a justified decision (here: not justified now, as a backstop).
Watch out for
Listing advantages and disadvantages without a criterion or a decision.
Using data without its date and source.