Lesson 2: Opportunity cost and decision-making
A government's opportunity cost
SkillsOpportunity cost in decisionsScarcity and the economic problem
Worked example
A state government has $1.5 billion of uncommitted funds. Its cabinet ranks three uses: (1) build two new regional hospitals, (2) cut payroll tax for small businesses, (3) upgrade a highway. It builds the hospitals.
Identify the opportunity cost of the decision and explain why voters might disagree about whether it was the right choice.
Step 1: Identify the next best alternative
The cabinet's second choice was the payroll tax cut, so the opportunity cost of the hospitals is the tax cut and the benefits it would have brought businesses and their workers.
Step 2: Note what the opportunity cost is not
It is not the $1.5 billion itself (that is the money cost), and not the highway as well, which was ranked third.
Step 3: Explain why judgements differ
Different voters weigh the benefits subjectively. A family in a regional town may value the hospitals far above a tax cut; a small business owner may rank the tax cut first. Each is judging the same trade-off with different preferences.
Answer
The opportunity cost is the payroll tax cut, the next best use of the funds. Voters may disagree because they measure the benefits of the hospitals against those of the tax cut subjectively.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
The opportunity cost is the next best alternative, by the decision-maker's ranking.
The money spent is not the opportunity cost; it is what the money could have done instead.
Disagreement comes from subjective valuation of benefits.