Lesson 8: Economic systems and how they answer the three questions
Using data to compare two economic systems
SkillsComparing economic systemsThe three economic questions
Worked example
Use the information below to analyse how Singapore and Cuba answer the question "for whom to produce?" for housing and food.
- Singapore: ranked 1st (score 84.1) in the Heritage Foundation's 2025 Index of Economic Freedom; 76.0% of the resident population lived in public HDB flats in the 2024–25 financial year.
- Cuba: ranked 175th (score 25.4) in the same index; basic food has been distributed through a ration book since 1962; private small and medium businesses were legalised in August 2021.
Step 1: Read Singapore's evidence
The index shows that markets answer most questions in Singapore. But for housing, the state builds the flats most residents live in (76.0% in 2024–25), so government plays a large part in answering for whom for housing.
Step 2: Read Cuba's evidence
Cuba's low score shows a mostly planned economy. The ration book means the state, not prices, decides for whom basic food is produced: a set quantity per person.
Step 3: Note the change in Cuba
Legalising private businesses in 2021 lets markets answer some questions, so Cuba has moved a little towards the mixed part of the spectrum.
Step 4: Compare
Both use government to answer "for whom" for an essential good, but in different ways: Singapore inside a market economy, through public housing that households buy; Cuba through rationing in a planned economy.
Step 5: Note the limits of the evidence
The index measures market orientation, not living standards or equity, and comes from a free-market research institute, so it shows how each economy is organised, not which one serves its people better.
Answer
Singapore is strongly market-oriented (1st in 2025) yet the state provides housing for about three-quarters of residents, so government answers "for whom" for housing within a market economy. Cuba is mostly planned (175th) and answers "for whom" for basic food by rationing, though it has allowed private businesses since 2021. The data show how each is organised, not which delivers better outcomes.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.