Lesson 11: Investigating an Australian market
Explaining the fall in wool prices, 2018 to 2020
SkillsAnalysing an Australian marketShifting demand and supply
Worked example
Stimulus: The Eastern Market Indicator (EMI), the benchmark price of Australian wool, reached a record of about 2,116 cents a kilogram (clean) in August 2018. Drought had cut the national wool clip. By the end of June 2020 the EMI was about 1,110 cents. Over 2019 the United States and China raised tariffs on each other's goods, and in 2020 clothing stores around the world closed during COVID-19 lockdowns. Most Australian wool is processed in China.
(a) Calculate the percentage change in the EMI from August 2018 to June 2020.
(b) Analyse the changes in the wool market over the period, using demand and supply.
(c) Evaluate the effect on Australian woolgrowers.
Step 1: (a) Percentage change
(to 1 decimal place). The price nearly halved.
Step 2: (b) 2018, the rise to the peak
Drought forced growers to reduce flocks, so less wool was offered at every price: supply shifted left, raising the price to the August 2018 record.
Step 3: (b) 2019–20, the fall
Tariffs and uncertainty slowed Chinese and US demand for wool garments, and in 2020 shop closures cut retail sales of clothing worldwide. Processors in China needed less raw wool: demand shifted left. At the old price there was a surplus at auction, bales were passed in, and the price fell to a new equilibrium at a lower price and a lower quantity sold.
Step 4: (b) Why the fall was so large
In the short run the supply of wool is inelastic: sheep grow wool whatever its price, and flocks take years to rebuild or reduce. With a steep supply curve, a fall in demand shows up mostly as a fall in price rather than in quantity.
This links elasticity to the size of the price change, which is what earns the analysis marks.
Step 5: (c) Evaluate
Woolgrowers' revenue fell sharply, since they could not cut output quickly; many stored wool hoping for a recovery, and some shifted towards meat sheep. Those who also sold lamb were partly protected by strong lamb prices. In the short run growers bore most of the fall in demand; in the long run the low price signalled resources to move out of wool, which is the price mechanism working but at a real cost to wool-dependent farms.
Answer
(a) −47.5%. (b) Drought shifted supply left (price up to 2018); trade tensions and COVID-19 shifted demand left (price down), and inelastic short-run supply made the price fall large. (c) Growers bore a large fall in revenue in the short run; the price signal moved resources towards meat sheep over time.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate any change asked for from the original value.
Split the period into phases and identify one shift for each.
Use elasticity to explain the size of the price change.
Evaluate with a judgement: who bore the change, short run and long run.
Watch out for
Dividing by the 2020 value, giving −90.6%.
Shifting supply right to explain the fall in price: the evidence (tariffs, shop closures) points to demand.