Lesson 8: Booms, busts and the paradox of thrift
Show the paradox of thrift with numbers
SkillsThe paradox of thriftEquilibrium in the circular flow
Worked example
A closed economy has no government. Investment is $120 billion a year and does not change. Households save 15% of their income.
(a) Find the equilibrium level of national income. (b) Worried about a downturn, households decide to save 20% of their income. Find the new equilibrium income and total saving. (c) Explain why this result is called the paradox of thrift.
Step 1: The equilibrium condition here
The only withdrawal is saving and the only injection is investment, so equilibrium needs , that is .
In a two-sector economy with a financial sector only, injections equal withdrawals reduces to S = I.
Step 2: Starting income
billion. Saving is billion.
Step 3: New income
Now , so billion.
Step 4: New total saving
billion: unchanged.
Step 5: Explain the paradox
Each household saved a larger share, but spending fell, so incomes fell by $200 billion until saving was back to the level of investment. The attempt to save more left total saving the same and the economy poorer.
Answer
(a) $800 billion. (b) Income falls to $600 billion and total saving stays at $120 billion. (c) Saving more is sensible for one household, but when all households do it, spending and income fall, so total saving does not rise: a fallacy of composition.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Write the equilibrium condition (here , with a share of income).
Solve for income before and after the change.
Compare total saving and income, and name the fallacy of composition.
Watch out for
Calculating new saving as 20% of the old income ($160 billion). Income falls, so 20% of the new income is still $120 billion.