Lesson 7: Average and instantaneous rates from graphs
Matching rate curves to changed conditions
SkillsRates from graphsFactors that change the rate
Worked example
Excess marble chips react with of hydrochloric acid at 25 °C, and the volume of (at STP) is recorded: the curve marked original. The experiment is repeated three times, changing one thing each time:
- the same mass of marble, but powdered;
- of acid;
- of acid.
(a) Show that the original experiment produces a final volume of about .
(b) Match each change to curve P, Q or R, and justify each choice.
Step 1: Moles of the limiting reactant
The marble is in excess, so the acid is limiting. .
Step 2: Final volume of gas
, so .
Step 3: Change 1, powdered marble → P
Larger surface area, same acid: more frequent collisions, so a steeper start. The acid is unchanged, so the same final volume. Only P fits.
Step 4: Change 2, 20.0 mL of 0.200 mol L⁻¹ acid → Q
Lower concentration: fewer collisions per second, so a less steep start. Moles of HCl , half the original, so half the final volume (about 45 mL): Q.
Step 5: Change 3, 40.0 mL of 0.200 mol L⁻¹ acid → R
The same lower concentration, so the same less steep start as Q. But moles of HCl , the same as the original, so it heads for the same 91 mL: R.
Concentration decides how fast the curve starts; moles of limiting reactant decide where it ends. Change 3 lowers one without the other.
Answer
(a) , at STP. (b) 1 → P (steeper, same final volume); 2 → Q (less steep, half the volume); 3 → R (less steep, same final volume).
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Volume of against time for the original experiment and three changes.
Method
Find the limiting reactant and the final amount of product.
Starting gradient: concentration, temperature, surface area, catalyst.
Final level: moles of the limiting reactant only.
Watch out for
Assuming a lower concentration always means less product. Change 3 has a lower concentration but the same number of moles.
Thinking a larger surface area makes more gas. It only makes it faster.