Lesson 7: Line spectra and the Bohr model
Which gases are in the discharge tube?
SkillEmission and absorption spectra
Worked example
A discharge tube contains a mixture of gases. Its emission spectrum has lines at 405, 436, 447, 502, 546, 588 and 668 nm. Reference emission lines (nm) are:
| Element | Lines (nm) |
|---|---|
| Hydrogen | 410, 434, 486, 656 |
| Helium | 447, 471, 492, 502, 588, 668 |
| Mercury | 405, 436, 546, 577, 579 |
Identify the gases in the tube, justifying your answer, and explain why each element has its own set of lines.
Step 1: Match each observed line
- 405, 436 and 546 nm match mercury.
- 447, 502, 588 and 668 nm match helium.
Every observed line is accounted for.
Step 2: Test each candidate fully
Hydrogen's two strongest visible lines, 486 nm and the red 656 nm line, are both missing, so hydrogen is not present. (The 436 nm line is close to hydrogen's 434 nm, but it belongs to mercury, which also explains 405 and 546 nm.)
One close match is not enough. An element is present only if its lines appear together, especially its strongest ones.
Step 3: Note the missing lines of the gases present
Some reference lines (helium 471 and 492 nm, mercury 577 and 579 nm) are not listed. Weak lines may be too faint to record, and 577 and 579 nm may not be resolved, so their absence does not rule the element out when its other lines are clearly present.
Step 4: Explain why each element is unique
Each line comes from an electron falling between two energy levels, with an energy equal to the gap. Each element has a different nuclear charge and number of electrons, so a different set of energy levels and therefore a unique set of lines.
Answer
The tube contains mercury and helium, not hydrogen: all seven lines match these two elements, and hydrogen's strongest lines (486 and 656 nm) are absent. Each element has its own energy levels, so its own unique set of emission lines.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Match every observed line to a reference.
Check that each element you claim has its main lines present.
Rule out elements whose strongest lines are missing.
Watch out for
Claiming an element from a single line that falls close to one of its lines.
Ruling an element out because one weak line is missing.