Lesson 12: Fuels, food and industry: energy in society
Evaluate ethanol and octane as car fuels
SkillFuels and energy in society
Worked example
Petrol is mostly octane, (). Bioethanol, (), is made by fermenting sugar cane.
(a) Calculate the energy released per gram of each fuel.
(b) Calculate the mass of carbon dioxide released per megajoule (1000 kJ) of energy for each fuel.
(c) Evaluate the two fuels for use in cars.
Step 1: (a) Energy per gram
, so .
, so .
Step 2: (b) Carbon dioxide per megajoule
Octane: , so 1 mol of octane gives 8 mol of () and 5470 kJ: .
Ethanol: 1 mol gives 2 mol of () and 1367 kJ: .
Comparing per megajoule puts the fuels on an equal footing: it is the emitted for the same useful energy.
Step 3: (c) Energy output and suitability
Octane releases about 60 % more energy per gram, so a tank of petrol takes a car further, and engines are built for it. Ethanol is also a liquid that is easy to store and pump, but a car needs more of it per kilometre; it is usually blended with petrol (E10) or used in modified engines.
Step 4: (c) Combustion products
At the exhaust pipe both release the same mass of per megajoule. But the carbon in bioethanol was taken from the air by the sugar cane only months earlier, so over its life cycle it adds far less new than petrol, whose carbon was locked away for millions of years. Ethanol contains oxygen, so it burns more completely (less CO and soot), and it contains no sulfur.
Step 5: (c) Judgement
Bioethanol is the better choice for reducing greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, and it is renewable, but it gives less energy per gram and growing the crop uses land, water and energy. Blending it with petrol balances energy output with lower net emissions.
Answer
(a) Octane , ethanol (b) both of per MJ (c) Octane gives more energy per gram; ethanol is renewable, burns more cleanly and has much lower life-cycle , so it is the better choice for emissions, ideally blended with petrol.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Energy per gram = heat of combustion ÷ molar mass.
Compare per unit of energy, not per mole.
Evaluate energy output, suitability and products, then make a judgement with a reason.
Watch out for
Comparing heats of combustion per mole: octane looks four times better, but a mole of octane is 2.5 times heavier.
Giving a judgement without the evidence (numbers) and a limitation.