Lesson 6: Regulating gene expression
Explaining a four-winged fly
SkillGene regulation and HOX genes
Worked example
Normal fruit flies have two wings on the second thoracic segment (T2) and two small halteres (balancing organs) on the third (T3). The HOX gene Ultrabithorax (Ubx) is normally expressed in T3 but not T2. Flies with mutations that stop Ubx being expressed in T3 have four wings.
Explain how the absence of one HOX gene's expression produces a whole extra pair of wings, and why this shows HOX genes regulate morphology.
Step 1: What Ubx is
Ubx codes for a transcription factor with a homeodomain that binds DNA at the promoters of many target genes.
Step 2: What it does in T3
In normal T3 cells, Ubx protein represses genes needed for wing development and activates genes that build a haltere, so T3 develops its own identity.
One transcription factor controls a whole set of downstream genes, so it controls the development of an entire structure.
Step 3: Without Ubx in T3
With no Ubx protein, the wing genes in T3 are not repressed. T3 cells follow the T2 program (the "default" without Ubx) and develop wings instead of halteres: four wings.
Step 4: Why this shows regulation of morphology
No wing genes were added or changed; the same genes were simply switched on in a different place. A HOX gene determines a segment's identity by controlling which genes are expressed there, so it shapes the body plan.
Answer
Ubx is a transcription factor that normally switches off wing-development genes and switches on haltere genes in T3. Without it, T3 expresses the T2 (wing) program and grows wings. HOX genes regulate morphology by controlling which sets of genes are expressed in each segment.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Identify the HOX protein as a transcription factor.
Say which target genes it switches on or off, and where.
Explain the mutant as the wrong program running in a segment.
Watch out for
Saying the mutation "adds wing genes".
Forgetting that the HOX protein acts by binding DNA (it is a transcription factor).