Lesson 1: The structure of DNA

Investigating salt and DNA yield from strawberries

SkillDNA structure and base pairing

Worked example

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology active

A student investigated how the concentration of salt in the extraction buffer affects the mass of DNA precipitated from strawberries. For each trial, 20 g of strawberry was mashed with 10 mL of buffer (detergent plus salt), filtered, and the DNA precipitated with ice-cold ethanol and weighed wet.

Salt (g per 100 mL)Trial 1 (g)Trial 2 (g)Trial 3 (g)
00.080.100.09
0.50.210.190.23
1.00.320.350.33
1.50.360.200.37
2.00.350.370.36

(a) Identify the anomalous result and calculate the mean for each concentration. (b) Describe the trend and explain it in terms of the structure of DNA. (c) Evaluate the validity of using wet mass as the measure of DNA, and suggest two improvements.

1 of 5 steps
  1. Step 1: Spot the anomaly

    At 1.5 g per 100 mL, trial 2 (0.20 g) is far below the other two (0.36, 0.37) and below the result at 1.0 g. Exclude it.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Identify anomalies before averaging, and say why you excluded them.

  2. Describe the trend with numbers, then explain it with a property of DNA.

  3. Validity: does the measurement really measure the variable? Suggest specific improvements.

Watch out for

  • Including the anomaly in the mean (0.31 g), which hides the plateau.

  • Explaining salt's role as "breaking down the membranes" (that is the detergent).

Save your progress with a free account