Lesson 12: Comparing ecosystems across space and time
Read a pollen and charcoal core
SkillsComparing ecosystems in space and timeEcological succession
Worked example
A sediment core was taken from a swamp on a tableland in north Queensland. The table summarises the pollen and charcoal in five layers (illustrative data based on the kind of record such cores give).
| Depth (m) | Age (thousand years ago) | Rainforest pollen (%) | Eucalypt and other sclerophyll pollen (%) | Grass pollen (%) | Charcoal (particles per ) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(a) Describe how the vegetation changed between 60 000 and 25 000 years ago. (b) Describe the relationship between charcoal and the type of vegetation. (c) Propose an explanation for the change, and state what other evidence would help test it. (d) Give two limitations of using pollen percentages to reconstruct past vegetation.
Step 1: Read the core from the bottom up
Deeper layers are older, so read from (60 000 years ago) upwards.
Step 2: Vegetation change
Rainforest pollen fell from (60 000 years ago) to (25 000 years ago), while sclerophyll pollen rose from to and grass from to . The biggest change was between 45 000 and 38 000 years ago. The vegetation changed from rainforest to more open, fire-tolerant sclerophyll forest and woodland.
Step 3: Charcoal and vegetation
Charcoal rose from – to – particles per at the same time as sclerophyll and grass pollen increased: more fire is associated with more fire-tolerant vegetation (a positive correlation), and rainforest pollen is highest when charcoal is lowest.
Step 4: Possible explanation
More frequent fire (from a drier climate, or from changed burning after people arrived, or from fuel building up after large herbivores declined) killed fire-sensitive rainforest plants and favoured fire-tolerant eucalypts and grasses. To test between these, look for climate evidence in the same layers (for example, other indicators of rainfall), dung-fungus spores (Sporormiella) as a record of large herbivores, and archaeological dates for human arrival in the region.
Step 5: Limitations
Plants produce and disperse different amounts of pollen (wind-pollinated eucalypts and grasses produce far more than many animal-pollinated rainforest trees), so percentages do not equal cover. Pollen can blow in from far away. Dates of layers carry uncertainty, and a correlation between charcoal and vegetation does not show which caused which.
Answer
(a) Rainforest pollen fell from 78 % to 22 % and sclerophyll and grass pollen rose, mostly between 45 000 and 38 000 years ago. (b) Charcoal rose as sclerophyll and grass pollen rose: more fire with more fire-tolerant vegetation. (c) Increased fire (climate, people or megafaunal decline) favoured fire-tolerant plants; test with climate proxies, Sporormiella and archaeological dates. (d) Unequal pollen production and dispersal; long-distance pollen; dating uncertainty; correlation not cause.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Deeper is older: read a core from the bottom up.
Describe change with numbers and identify when it was fastest.
Treat links between records as correlations and name evidence that could test the cause.
Watch out for
Reading the core top-down as if the top were oldest.
Stating that people caused the change as a fact.