Lesson 11 of 11 · 20 min
Water balance in plants and stomatal data
Explain how stomata, guard cells, vacuoles, the cuticle and abscisic acid keep a plant's water balance, calculate stomatal density from microscope counts, and compare stomata in plants from dry, wet and aquatic environments.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how guard cells open and close stomata, and how abscisic acid closes them when a plant is short of water.
- Explain the roles of the cuticle and vacuoles in water balance.
- Calculate stomatal density from counts in a field of view of known diameter.
- Interpret and evaluate data comparing the number and distribution of stomata in plants adapted to different environments.
- Plan an investigation of the tolerance of a plant to water or salt stress.
A plant cannot walk to water or sweat less on a hot day, yet it must keep its tissues hydrated. It takes water in through its roots and loses it, mostly as water vapour through the stomata of its leaves (transpiration, from Unit 1). Every open stoma is a trade: carbon dioxide in for photosynthesis, water out. Water balance in plants is about managing that trade.
Guard cells open and close the stomata. Each stoma is a pore between two guard cells. Their inner walls, next to the pore, are thicker and less stretchy than their outer walls, and cellulose fibres run around them like hoops.
- Opening: in the light, guard cells actively pump potassium ions () in from the surrounding cells. Their solute concentration rises, so water enters them by osmosis. As they swell and become turgid, the thin outer walls stretch more than the thick inner walls, the cells bow apart and the pore opens.
- Closing: ions leave, water follows by osmosis, the guard cells become flaccid and the pore closes.
An open stoma. The guard cells are turgid, and their thick inner walls make them bow apart.
Change the light, the water supply and abscisic acid, and watch the guard cells. What makes the stoma close?
Which sequence correctly explains how a stoma opens?
Abscisic acid closes the stomata when water runs short. When the soil dries out or the leaves begin to wilt, roots and leaves make the hormone abscisic acid (ABA). It travels in the xylem to the leaves, enters the guard cells and binds to receptor proteins inside them. Signal transduction opens ion channels: (and chloride) ions leave the guard cells, water follows by osmosis, the guard cells become flaccid and the stomata close, usually within minutes. Transpiration falls and the plant's remaining water is conserved. When water returns, ABA is broken down and the stomata reopen.
This is a negative feedback loop, though plants have no brain: the cells that sense the water shortage are also the ones that make the signal.
Abscisic acid and stomatal closure as negative feedback.
Pore width of stomata on a leaf strip before and after abscisic acid is added at 5 minutes. (Model data.)
From the graph, the pore width falls from 8 µm before abscisic acid is added to 2 µm at 30 minutes. Calculate the percentage decrease in pore width.
The cuticle. The epidermis of leaves and young stems is covered by a cuticle of waxes and cutin that is almost waterproof. In most plants only a small fraction (typically less than a tenth) of the water lost passes through it, so closing the stomata really does cut water loss. Plants of dry habitats, such as eucalypts and hakeas, have thick, waxy cuticles; many eucalypts are blue-grey because of the wax on their leaves.
Vacuoles. Most plant cells have a large central vacuole filled with cell sap. It stores water, and the solutes in it (sugars, salts) draw water into the cell by osmosis, keeping the cell turgid. Turgid cells push against their walls and hold soft leaves and stems up; when a plant loses more water than it takes in, its vacuoles shrink and it wilts. Plants of salty soils, such as saltbushes, move salt into their vacuoles, away from the enzymes in the cytoplasm, and the stored salt helps their cells draw water from salty soil by osmosis. Saltbushes also pack salt into the vacuoles of bladder-like hairs on the leaf surface, which burst and shed it.
| Environment | Examples | Stomata | Other features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry (xerophytes) | Spinifex (Triodia), eucalypts, banksias, she-oaks, wattles | Protected rather than exposed: sunken in pits or grooves, often lined with hairs, or only on the lower or inner surface (inside the rolled leaf of spinifex); often fewer on exposed surfaces | Thick waxy cuticle; small, hanging or rolled leaves; she-oaks have tiny scale leaves and stomata in grooves along the branchlets; wattles have flattened leaf stalks (phyllodes) |
| Moderate (mesophytes) | Beans, hibiscus, most garden plants | Many more on the lower surface than the upper | Moderate cuticle; broad leaves |
| Floating in water (hydrophytes) | Water lilies | On the upper surface only (the lower surface is in water) | Thin cuticle; air spaces that keep the leaf afloat |
| Submerged | Ribbon weed (Vallisneria) | Few or none | Very thin cuticle; gases diffuse through the leaf surface |
Start with a leaf from a moist place and add the thick cuticle, fewer stomata, sunken stomata, hairs and a rolled leaf, one at a time.
Pits, grooves and hairs trap a layer of still, humid air over the stomata, so water vapour diffuses away more slowly. Do not expect every dry-country plant to have few stomata: some have many small ones. What saves water is where the stomata are, how well they are protected, and how quickly they close.
Key idea
Stomatal density
Stomatal density is the number of stomata per unit area of leaf surface:
For a circular field of view of diameter , the area is with . Count several fields of view, from several leaves, and use the mean.
Worked example
Calculate stomatal density at high power
A student measures the field of view of a microscope at ×100 as 1.8 mm in diameter. They then count the stomata in five fields of view of a nail-varnish peel of the lower epidermis of a leaf at ×400.
| Field | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stomata counted | 22 | 25 | 24 | 27 | 22 |
Calculate the stomatal density of the lower epidermis in stomata per mm², to two significant figures.
Step 1: Find the field of view at ×400
.
Four times the magnification shows a field of view a quarter as wide.
Step 2: Find its area
, so .
Step 3: Find the mean count
stomata per field.
Step 4: Calculate the density
, which is stomata per to two significant figures.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
About 150 stomata per mm² (2 s.f.).
Method
Scale the field of view: diameter × (low magnification ÷ high magnification).
Area = πr², with r half the diameter.
Density = mean count ÷ area.
Watch out for
Using the diameter in πr² instead of the radius (gives a density four times too small).
Multiplying the field of view by 4 instead of dividing.
Tap each stoma to count it, move to a new field, and the density is worked out from the field area. Compare the surfaces of plants from different environments.
A student counts 36 stomata in a field of view of diameter 0.50 mm on the lower epidermis of a bean leaf. Calculate the stomatal density, in stomata per mm², to two significant figures.
Worked example
Compare stomata in plants from different environments
A class made nail-varnish peels from both surfaces of a leaf of each of three plants: a bean, a water lily and a banksia. They counted the stomata in five fields of view (area 0.159 mm²) on each surface.
| Plant and surface | Field 1 | Field 2 | Field 3 | Field 4 | Field 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bean, upper | 6 | 8 | 5 | 7 | 9 |
| Bean, lower | 38 | 42 | 35 | 40 | 45 |
| Water lily, upper | 75 | 82 | 70 | 79 | 84 |
| Water lily, lower | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Banksia, upper | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Banksia, lower (in hairy pits) | 18 | 22 | 20 | 17 | 23 |
(a) Calculate the mean stomatal density of each surface. (b) Relate the distribution of stomata in each plant to its environment. (c) Evaluate the reliability of the data and suggest one improvement.
Step 1: Means per field
Bean upper , bean lower ; water lily upper ; banksia lower ; the other surfaces .
Step 2: Densities
Divide each mean by : bean upper , bean lower , water lily upper , banksia lower stomata per (2 s.f.); water lily lower and banksia upper .
Step 3: Bean (mesophyte)
Most of the bean's stomata (about 85 %) are on the shaded lower surface, which is cooler and less exposed to wind, so less water is lost than if they were on top.
Step 4: Water lily (floating hydrophyte)
Its stomata are all on the upper surface, the only one in contact with air; the lower surface rests on water, where stomata could not exchange gases. Water loss is not a problem for a plant floating on water.
Step 5: Banksia (xerophyte)
Its stomata are only on the lower surface and sunk in pits lined with hairs, which trap humid air over the pores and slow the diffusion of water vapour away, conserving water in a dry habitat.
Step 6: Evaluate
Five fields per surface and consistent counts (bean lower ranges only from 35 to 45) suggest the counts are fairly reliable for these leaves, but only one leaf of each plant was sampled, so the results may not represent the species. Improvement: sample several leaves of the same age from several plants of each species and report the mean and range.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Bean upper 44 and lower 250; water lily upper 490 and lower 0; banksia upper 0 and lower 130 stomata per mm². (b) Bean: most on the shaded lower surface; water lily: only on the upper surface, which is in air; banksia: only on the lower surface, in hairy pits that reduce water loss. (c) Repeated fields with small spread, but only one leaf per plant; sample more leaves and plants.
Method
Mean per field, then divide by the field area for density.
For each plant, link where the stomata are to the conditions it lives in.
Reliability: number of repeats, spread, sample size. Suggest a specific improvement.
Watch out for
Concluding that dry-country plants always have the fewest stomata. The banksia saves water by where and how its stomata are placed.
Comparing counts per field without converting to density when field areas differ.
Tip
Making a reliable count
- Paint a thin layer of clear nail varnish on the leaf surface, let it dry, lift it off with clear tape and mount it on a slide. This peel copies the epidermis.
- Use the same magnification (often ×400) for every count, and find the field of view diameter with a stage micrometer.
- Count stomata cut by the edge of the field on two sides only (for example, the top and left), so that you do not count edge stomata twice across fields.
- Count at least five fields per leaf, on several leaves of the same age, taken from the same part of each plant, and report the mean.
Note
Investigating water and salt tolerance
To find the tolerance limits of a plant for salt, grow groups of identical seedlings (for example mung beans or radish) watered with sodium chloride solutions of 0, 25, 50, 100 and 200 mmol L⁻¹. After two weeks, measure the height, the number of leaves or the dry mass of each. The independent variable is the salt concentration; the dependent variable is growth; the 0 mmol L⁻¹ group is the control. Keep the soil, volume of solution, light, temperature and pot size the same. The tolerance range is the set of concentrations where growth stays near the control; the limit is where growth falls sharply or plants die. For water stress, vary the volume of water given instead. Use at least five plants per group and graph mean growth against concentration.
Worked example
Find the salt tolerance limit of mung beans
Groups of five mung bean seedlings were watered with sodium chloride solutions for 14 days, and their mean increase in height was recorded.
| NaCl concentration (mmol L⁻¹) | 0 | 25 | 50 | 100 | 200 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean height increase (cm) | 12.4 | 12.1 | 10.8 | 6.2 | 0.9 |
(a) Express each mean as a percentage of the control. (b) Describe the trend and estimate the tolerance limit. (c) Explain why high salt concentrations reduce growth. (d) Identify one controlled variable and suggest one improvement.
Step 1: Percentages of the control
: ; : ; : ; : (the group is ).
Step 2: Describe the trend
Growth is almost unaffected up to 25 mmol L⁻¹, falls a little by 50 mmol L⁻¹, halves by 100 mmol L⁻¹ and almost stops at 200 mmol L⁻¹.
Step 3: Estimate the tolerance limit
Growth stays close to the control up to about 50 mmol L⁻¹ and falls sharply above it, so the tolerance limit is between about 50 and 100 mmol L⁻¹. Testing concentrations in that range would pin it down.
Step 4: Explain
Salty soil water has a high solute concentration, so less water moves into the roots by osmosis, and at high concentrations water may leave the root cells. The cells lose turgor and the plant closes its stomata (abscisic acid) to save water, which also cuts photosynthesis. Sodium and chloride ions taken up can also inhibit enzymes in the cytoplasm.
Step 5: Controls and improvement
Controlled variable: the volume of solution given each day (or the soil, light, temperature, pot size). Improvement: use more seedlings per group, repeat the experiment, and measure dry mass, which reflects growth better than height.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 100, 98, 87, 50 and 7 %. (b) Growth falls as salt concentration rises, slowly at first and steeply above about 50 mmol L⁻¹; the tolerance limit is between about 50 and 100 mmol L⁻¹. (c) Salt lowers water uptake by osmosis, so cells lose turgor and stomata close, reducing photosynthesis; ions can inhibit enzymes. (d) For example, the volume of solution; use more plants and measure dry mass.
Method
Percentage of control = treatment mean ÷ control mean × 100.
Describe where the trend changes, with numbers.
Explain with osmosis, turgor and stomatal closure.
Watch out for
Giving one exact concentration as the limit when the data only bracket it.
Saying salt "absorbs" water from the plant without mentioning osmosis.
Summary
Guard cells open a stoma when they take up , gain water by osmosis and become turgid, and close it when they lose and water and become flaccid.
When water is short, roots and leaves make abscisic acid, which makes guard cells lose and water, closing the stomata and cutting transpiration: negative feedback.
The waxy cuticle stops most water loss except through stomata; vacuoles store water and solutes and keep cells turgid.
Stomatal density = count ÷ area of the field of view (), averaged over several fields and leaves.
Xerophytes have protected stomata (sunken, in grooves or hairy pits, or only on the sheltered surface) and thick cuticles; mesophytes have most stomata on the lower surface; floating hydrophytes have them on the upper surface.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.