Lesson 2: Enzymes and the active site
Compare the lock-and-key and induced-fit models
SkillEnzymes and the active site
Worked example
Compare the lock-and-key and induced-fit models of enzyme action. Give one similarity, two differences, and explain which observation the induced-fit model accounts for better.
Step 1: A similarity
In both models the substrate binds to the active site to form an enzyme–substrate complex, the reaction occurs, the products are released and the enzyme is unchanged. Both explain specificity: only a substrate with a complementary shape can bind.
Step 2: First difference
Lock-and-key: the active site is rigid and already exactly complementary to the substrate. Induced fit: the active site is flexible and changes shape as the substrate binds.
Step 3: Second difference
In the induced-fit model the change in shape strains the substrate's bonds, which explains how the enzyme lowers the activation energy. The lock-and-key model does not explain this.
Step 4: An observation induced fit explains better
Some enzymes act on a small group of similar substrates, and X-ray structures show that many enzymes change shape when the substrate binds. A rigid lock fits only one key and never changes, so only the induced-fit model accounts for these.
"Compare" wants both similarities and differences, written as a comparison ("whereas"), not two separate descriptions.
Answer
Both: substrate binds to a complementary active site, forming an enzyme–substrate complex; explains specificity. Lock-and-key: rigid active site, exact fit before binding. Induced fit: flexible active site that moulds around the substrate, straining its bonds; it explains shape changes seen in enzyme structures and enzymes that act on several similar substrates.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State what both models share.
Contrast rigid against flexible, and fit before against fit during binding.
Name the evidence only induced fit explains.
Watch out for
Saying the substrate changes shape to fit in the induced-fit model. The active site changes shape.
Describing each model separately without comparing them.