Lesson 10: Cell size, surface area to volume ratio and diffusion

Analyse and evaluate an agar cube investigation

SkillsDiffusion experiment dataSurface area to volume ratio

Worked example

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology active

Agar cubes containing sodium hydroxide and phenolphthalein (pink) were left in 0.1 mol L⁻¹ hydrochloric acid for 10 minutes, then cut in half. The depth of the colourless band was measured with a ruler marked in millimetres, estimating between the marks to 0.1 mm.

Side of cube (cm)Depth, trial 1 (mm)Depth, trial 2 (mm)Depth, trial 3 (mm)
12.52.52.2
22.52.42.6
32.62.52.4

(a) Calculate the SA:V ratio and mean depth for each cube, and the percentage of each cube's volume reached by the acid. (b) Describe the relationship shown and draw a conclusion relevant to cells. (c) Evaluate the reliability of the data and suggest two improvements.

1 of 7 steps
  1. Step 1: (a) SA:V for each cube

    SA:V=6L2L3=6L\text{SA:V} = \dfrac{6L^2}{L^3} = \dfrac{6}{L}: 1 cm cube 6:16 : 1, 2 cm cube 3:13 : 1, 3 cm cube 2:12 : 1.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Calculate SA:V as 6/L and average the repeat trials.

  2. % reached uses the core of side L − 2d.

  3. Describe the trend with values, then link it to cell size.

  4. Judge reliability from the spread of repeats, precision from the instrument's uncertainty, and suggest specific fixes.

Watch out for

  • Concluding that acid diffuses faster into small cubes.

  • Using L−dL - d for the core instead of L−2dL - 2d.

Save your progress with a free account