Lesson 10: Cell size, surface area to volume ratio and diffusion
Analyse and evaluate an agar cube investigation
SkillsDiffusion experiment dataSurface area to volume ratio
Worked example
Agar cubes containing sodium hydroxide and phenolphthalein (pink) were left in 0.1 mol L⁻¹ hydrochloric acid for 10 minutes, then cut in half. The depth of the colourless band was measured with a ruler marked in millimetres, estimating between the marks to 0.1 mm.
| Side of cube (cm) | Depth, trial 1 (mm) | Depth, trial 2 (mm) | Depth, trial 3 (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.2 |
| 2 | 2.5 | 2.4 | 2.6 |
| 3 | 2.6 | 2.5 | 2.4 |
(a) Calculate the SA:V ratio and mean depth for each cube, and the percentage of each cube's volume reached by the acid. (b) Describe the relationship shown and draw a conclusion relevant to cells. (c) Evaluate the reliability of the data and suggest two improvements.
Step 1: (a) SA:V for each cube
: 1 cm cube , 2 cm cube , 3 cm cube .
Step 2: (a) Mean depths
1 cm: ; 2 cm: ; 3 cm: .
Step 3: (a) Percentage reached
With in cm, .
- 1 cm:
- 2 cm:
- 3 cm:
Step 4: (b) Describe the relationship
The depth reached was about the same (2.4–2.5 mm) in every cube, but as the SA:V ratio decreased from to , the percentage of the volume reached fell from 85.9 % to 42.1 %.
Step 5: (b) Conclude for cells
Substances diffuse the same distance into a cell in a given time whatever its size, but a larger cell, with a smaller SA:V, has a much smaller fraction of its volume supplied in that time. Its centre would be short of materials, so cells must stay small, or be flat, long or folded.
Step 6: (c) Evaluate reliability
The three trials for each cube agree closely (ranges of 0.2–0.3 mm), so the results are reliable (repeatable). But the uncertainty of the ruler is (half its smallest division), about 20 % of a 2.5 mm depth and larger than the differences between cubes, so the readings to 0.1 mm claim more precision than the ruler has.
Step 7: (c) Suggest improvements
(1) Measure the band with digital calipers (to ), to reduce the uncertainty. (2) Measure the colour boundary at the same time after cutting, against a white background, by the same person, to make the subjective judgement consistent. Also acceptable: cut cubes with a template and measure their real sides; leave them longer so the bands are deeper.
Answer
(a) SA:V 6:1, 3:1, 2:1; mean depths 2.4, 2.5, 2.5 mm; 85.9 %, 57.8 %, 42.1 % reached. (b) Same depth, but the percentage reached falls as SA:V falls, so large cells cannot be supplied fast enough by diffusion. (c) Trials agree closely (reliable), but the ±0.5 mm ruler uncertainty is large relative to the depths; use calipers and a consistent method of judging the boundary.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate SA:V as 6/L and average the repeat trials.
% reached uses the core of side L − 2d.
Describe the trend with values, then link it to cell size.
Judge reliability from the spread of repeats, precision from the instrument's uncertainty, and suggest specific fixes.
Watch out for
Concluding that acid diffuses faster into small cubes.
Using for the core instead of .