Lesson 7: What 95% confidence means
Testing a label claim with a confidence interval
SkillsInterpreting confidence intervalsConfidence intervals for a meanModelling with sample means
Worked example
A drinks company labels its bottles "500 mL" and claims the mean fill is mL. A consumer group buys a random sample of bottles and finds mL and mL.
(a) Calculate an approximate 95% confidence interval for the mean fill , correct to 2 decimal places.
(b) Does the interval support the company's claim? Explain.
(c) The company replies that a 99% interval contains 500 mL. Verify this, and evaluate the company's argument.
Step 1: Calculate the 95% interval
Step 2: Compare with the claim
lies above the whole interval. A 95% interval misses the true mean only about 5% of the time, so the sample is evidence that the mean fill is less than 500 mL.
A value outside the interval is not a plausible value of at this confidence level.
Step 3: Calculate the 99% interval
It does contain , just.
Step 4: Evaluate the argument
The company is right that 500 is inside the 99% interval, but only at the very edge, and it is outside the 95% interval. A higher confidence level makes intervals wider, so it can always be raised until a claim fits. The evidence that the mean is below 500 mL is moderate: strong enough to question the claim at 95%, not at 99%. A larger sample would settle it.
Answer
(a) mL. (b) No: 500 mL is outside the interval, so the data are evidence that the mean fill is less than 500 mL. (c) The 99% interval is , which just contains 500; the claim is plausible only at the higher confidence level, so the evidence against it is moderate rather than conclusive.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Build the interval, then ask whether the claimed is inside.
Inside: plausible. Outside: evidence against the claim.
Remember that the conclusion can depend on the confidence level, and say so.
Watch out for
Saying the claim is "proved false": the interval gives evidence, not certainty.
Concluding the 95% interval has a 95% chance of containing 500 mL.