Lesson 7: Haney, Banks and Zimbardo (1973): the Stanford Prison Experiment
Evaluate the Stanford Prison Experiment
SkillsThe Stanford Prison ExperimentResearch methods in social psychology
Worked example
Haney, Banks and Zimbardo (1973) concluded that the roles, status and power of a prison situation, not personality, made guards abusive and prisoners passive.
Evaluate this conclusion, with reference to the critiques of Le Texier (2019). (5 marks)
Step 1: State the conclusion and its basis
The researchers screened 24 healthy students and randomly assigned them to roles, so they argued that differences in behaviour must have come from the situation.
Step 2: Critique 1, demand characteristics
Le Texier (2019) found in the archives that the guards were given precise instructions about how to treat prisoners, and the warden worked to elicit "tough-guard" behaviour. The guards knew the results that were wanted. Their behaviour may reflect what they thought was expected, not the power of the role.
Step 3: Critique 2, data collection
Less than 15% of about 150 hours was recorded (6 hours of video, 15 hours of audio), mostly dramatic events, so the evidence of escalating abuse may be unrepresentative.
Step 4: Critique 3, experience of participants
Prisoners could leave only for medical or psychiatric reasons, and the archives suggest at least one breakdown was acted to get out. The distress may partly reflect being unable to leave, and some evidence is unreliable.
Step 5: Weigh it up and judge
The study had a single run, about 21 participants and no control group, and the BBC prison study (Reicher and Haslam, 2006) did not find spontaneous tyranny. Judgement: the conclusion is weakly supported. The study shows that situations can influence behaviour, but it cannot show that roles alone produced cruelty.
Answer
The conclusion is weakly supported. Demand characteristics (guards instructed and briefed to be tough), selective data collection (under 15% recorded) and participants' inability to leave (and a possibly acted breakdown) offer other explanations; with one run and no control group, the study does not show that roles alone cause abuse.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State the claim and the evidence behind it.
Apply each criticism: what it is, the evidence, and what it does to the conclusion.
End with a clear judgement.
Watch out for
Listing criticisms without saying how each weakens the conclusion.
Saying the study proves people become evil in uniforms.