Lesson 8: Analysing a treatment trial
Draw a conclusion from a t-test on placebo data
SkillsAnalysing treatment trialsThe placebo effect
Worked example
In the fictional GAD trial, the placebo group (mean improvement 6.50 points, SD 1.60, n = 8) was compared with the no-treatment group (mean 2.50 points, SD 1.60, n = 8) using an unpaired t-test: , .
State suitable hypotheses for this comparison and draw a conclusion. Explain what the result shows about the placebo effect.
Step 1: Write the hypotheses
: there is no difference in mean improvement between the placebo and no-treatment groups. : there is a difference in mean improvement between the two groups.
Step 2: Compare p with 0.05
, so the difference is statistically significant.
Step 3: Decide
Reject .
Step 4: Interpret
Participants who took an inactive pill improved by 4.00 points more on average () than those who received nothing. Because the pill had no active ingredient and the groups were randomly allocated, the difference is evidence of a placebo effect.
Random allocation is what lets you put the difference down to the condition rather than to differences between participants.
Answer
, so reject : the placebo group improved significantly more (by 4.00 points) than the no-treatment group, showing a significant placebo effect in this trial.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Write (no difference) and in terms of the variables.
Compare p with 0.05 and decide about .
Interpret the difference in the context of the trial.
Watch out for
Concluding the placebo "worked" as a treatment for GAD: the result shows the effect of expectation, not an active ingredient.