Lesson 5: Reliability and validity of IQ and EQ tests
Interpret a score near a cut-off
SkillsReliability and validity of testsIQ scores and the normal curve
Worked example
A 14-year-old is assessed on the WISC-V. Her full-scale IQ is 72, reported with a 95% confidence interval of 67 to 78. Her teachers report that she manages everyday tasks, friendships and self-care well.
(a) Calculate the z-score of 72, to 2 decimal places. (b) Evaluate whether this result alone shows she has an intellectual disability.
Step 1: Calculate z
Step 2: Locate it on the curve
The score is just under 2 standard deviations below the mean. Using technology, about 3% of her age group score lower.
Step 3: Read the confidence interval
Her true score lies between 67 and 78 with 95% confidence. That range includes scores below 70 and scores well above it, so measurement error alone means the test cannot place her firmly either side of the cut-off.
Step 4: Apply the diagnostic criteria
The DSM-5-TR also requires deficits in adaptive functioning that began during development. Her teachers describe good everyday functioning, which does not fit the criteria.
Step 5: Judge
The IQ score alone does not show an intellectual disability. A psychologist would weigh it with a formal assessment of adaptive functioning, her history and possible influences on the day, such as anxiety, language or fatigue.
Answer
(a) . (b) No. The confidence interval spans the cut-off of about 70, and a diagnosis also needs deficits in adaptive functioning, which her teachers do not describe. The score is one piece of evidence to weigh with others.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Locate the score with a z-score.
Check whether the confidence interval crosses the cut-off.
Consider the other criteria and other evidence before judging.
Watch out for
Treating 72 as an exact value rather than an estimate with error.
Forgetting that diagnosis never rests on an IQ alone.