Lesson 10: Researching the brain
Evaluate a PET study of the brain and violence
SkillsResearching the brainPET, MRI, fMRI and EEG
Worked example
Raine, Buchsbaum and LaCasse (1997) used PET to compare the brains of 41 people charged with murder who pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity with 41 control participants, each matched to one of them for age and sex. During an attention task, the prefrontal cortex of the people charged with murder used less glucose, on average, than that of the controls.
(a) Identify the type of investigation, and explain why it is not a true experiment. (b) Explain why matching for age and sex improves the study. (c) A newspaper headline reads "Brain scans show damaged brains cause murder". Evaluate this claim.
Step 1: (a) Type of investigation
It is a quasi-experiment: it compares two groups that already existed (people charged with murder and people who were not). The researchers could not manipulate the variable or randomly allocate people to groups, so it is not a true experiment.
Step 2: (b) Why matching helps
Brain activity changes with age and differs between the sexes. Matching each person charged with murder with a control of the same age and sex stops these from being confounding variables, so a difference in glucose use is not simply due to one group being older or having more men.
Step 3: (c) Evaluate the headline
The study found a difference in average prefrontal activity, not that it causes murder. Other differences between the groups could explain it (head injuries, drug use, stress of the trial, mental illness), and low activity could be a result of their life experiences rather than a cause. The sample was also a particular group (pleading insanity), so it may not apply to other people who commit violence. The headline overstates the evidence.
Evaluating a claim means weighing it against what the evidence can show: the type of investigation sets the limit.
Answer
(a) A quasi-experiment: existing groups compared, no manipulation or random allocation. (b) Matching removes age and sex as confounding variables. (c) Not supported: a quasi-experiment shows a group difference, not cause; other variables could explain it; and the sample was atypical.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Name the type of investigation from whether the IV was manipulated and participants randomly allocated.
Explain a control by the confounding variable it removes.
Judge a claim against what that type of investigation can show.
Watch out for
Calling it an experiment because it has two groups. Without manipulation and random allocation it cannot show cause.
Treating a group average as true of every individual in the group.