Lesson 6: Early abuse and deprivation
Evaluate a study of deprivation and its ethics
SkillsEffects of abuse and deprivationResearch methods and ethics
Worked example
In the Bucharest Early Intervention Project (Nelson et al. 2007), children living in institutions were randomly allocated either to foster families recruited and supported by the project or to continue in institutional care. Children who had never lived in an institution were also tested. The foster care group made significant cognitive gains compared with the institutional group, and children placed earlier gained more.
(a) Explain why random allocation lets the researchers draw a stronger conclusion than a study that simply compared adopted and non-adopted children. (b) Describe what the results suggest about the effects of early deprivation on cognitive development. (c) Discuss whether the study was ethical.
Step 1: (a) Random allocation
When children are randomly allocated, differences such as health at birth or how long they had already been in care are spread evenly across the groups. In a study of adopted children, adoptive families may choose healthier or more responsive children, so the groups could differ before placement. Random allocation means a later difference is more likely to be caused by foster care.
Step 2: (b) What the results suggest
Institutional deprivation is associated with lower cognitive ability (the institutional group scored well below never-institutionalised children). Moving into responsive family care leads to recovery, and the earlier the placement, the greater the recovery, consistent with a sensitive period in the first years.
Step 3: (c) Ethical concerns
Leaving some children in institutions when foster care was available raises the concern of protection from harm. The children could not consent themselves, so consent depended on the authorities responsible for them.
Step 4: (c) How the concerns were addressed
Ethics committees in Romania and the US approved it. There was almost no foster care in Bucharest at the time, so no child lost a placement they would otherwise have had; the project created the places. Children in the institution group could still be adopted or placed by the authorities, no child was moved back into an institution, and the findings were shared with the government to improve care.
Step 5: (c) Reach a judgement
Given the safeguards and the benefit to many children, a strong case can be made that it was ethical, though people still debate whether randomising vulnerable children can ever be justified.
Answer
(a) Random allocation spreads pre-existing differences evenly, so differences after placement can be attributed to foster care. (b) Early deprivation harms cognitive development, and recovery is greater the earlier children receive family care. (c) The study raised concerns about harm and consent, addressed by ethics approval, creating rather than withholding foster care, allowing other placements, and sharing results; a reasoned judgement either way is acceptable.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Explain what random allocation controls.
State what the results show, including timing.
For ethics: name the principle at stake, how it was addressed, then judge.
Watch out for
Writing that the study "proved deprivation causes low IQ". It showed that foster care improves cognition compared with institutional care.
Describing the children's experiences in detail instead of the evidence. Keep to the findings.