Lesson 2: Horizontal launches
Reconstructing a car's speed from where it landed
SkillHorizontal launches
Worked example
A car failed to take a bend, left a horizontal road at the top of an embankment and landed in a paddock. Crash investigators measured that it landed horizontally from the edge of the road and below the level of the road. The speed limit was , and the driver says they were not speeding.
Model the car as a projectile launched horizontally with no drag. (a) Calculate the car's speed as it left the road. (b) Use the uncertainties to find the range of speeds consistent with the measurements. (c) Evaluate the driver's claim.
Step 1: Find the time of the fall
Up is positive. , , :
Step 2: Find the speed at the edge of the road
In kilometres per hour: , or to two significant figures.
Multiply by 3.6 to convert to , because .
Step 3: Find the largest speed the data allow
The speed is largest for the longest distance and the shortest fall (shortest time):
, so
Taking the extreme values of each measurement in the direction that pushes the answer up gives the upper bound of the result.
Step 4: Find the smallest speed the data allow
Shortest distance and longest fall:
, so
Step 5: Evaluate the claim against the evidence
Every speed consistent with the measurements, to , is above , so the evidence does not support the driver's claim.
The conclusion rests on the model. It assumes the car left the road horizontally, that drag was negligible over a one-second flight, and that both measurements locate the same point on the car. If the road sloped upwards at the edge, the car would have needed less speed to travel the same distance. A court needs evidence beyond reasonable doubt, so a careful report states the uncertainties and assumptions and compares the result with other evidence, such as tyre marks or the car's event data recorder.
In an evaluation, a calculated result is only as strong as the measurements and assumptions behind it. Naming them is what earns the marks.
Answer
(a) (). (b) Between about and . (c) The whole range is above the limit, so the measurements contradict the claim, provided the take-off was horizontal and the measurements refer to the same point on the car.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Use the fall height to find the time in the air.
Divide the horizontal distance by that time to get the launch speed.
Combine the extreme measurements to find the largest and smallest possible results.
Compare the whole range with the claim, then state the assumptions that could change the conclusion.
Watch out for
Quoting a single value without its uncertainty. A speed of alone hides whether is possible.
Pairing the extremes the wrong way (largest distance with the longest time), which narrows the range instead of bounding it.