Lesson 10: Mass defect and binding energy
Why fusion beats fission per nucleon
SkillsMass defect and binding energyMass–energy equivalenceTransmutation, fission and fusion
Worked example
A student claims that "fission is the better energy source because one fission releases about ten times as much energy as one fusion."
Use these reactions to evaluate the claim by comparing the percentage of mass transformed into energy and the energy released per nucleon.
- Fission: , mass decrease 0.186033 u, reactant mass 236.052595 u
- Fusion: , mass decrease 0.018883 u, reactant mass 5.030151 u
Take 1 u as equivalent to 934 MeV.
Step 1: Energy per reaction
Fission: MeV. Fusion: MeV. The claim's first part is right: one fission releases about 10 times as much.
Step 2: Percentage of mass transformed
Fission: . Fusion: .
The percentage of mass converted tells you the energy per kilogram of fuel.
Step 3: Energy per nucleon
Fission: MeV per nucleon. Fusion: MeV per nucleon.
Step 4: Compare
Fusion converts times the percentage of mass, and releases about 4.8 times as much energy per nucleon.
Step 5: Evaluate the claim
The claim compares single reactions, which involve very different numbers of nucleons (236 against 5). Per nucleon, and so per kilogram of fuel, fusion releases nearly five times as much energy because a greater percentage of the mass is transformed. The claim is not supported, although fission is currently the only one of the two that can be used in a power station.
Answer
One fission releases about 10 times the energy of one fusion, but fusion transforms about 0.375 % of the mass (against 0.0788 %) and releases about 3.5 MeV per nucleon (against 0.74 MeV), nearly five times as much per kilogram. The claim is not supported.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare like with like: per nucleon or per kilogram, not per reaction.
Percentage of mass transformed .
Finish with a judgement and its reason.
Watch out for
Dividing the fission energy by 235 and the fusion energy by 4: count every nucleon on the reactant side (236 and 5).