Lesson 7: Simulation, standardising and when the approximation works
When the normal approximation fails
SkillsNormal approximation for p̂Simulation and standardisingThe sample proportion
Worked example
A factory says 3 % of its light globes are faulty. An inspector tests a random sample of 50 globes.
(a) Find the mean and standard deviation of .
(b) A student uses the normal approximation to calculate . Find the value they get, correct to three decimal places, and explain why it shows the approximation is poor here.
(c) Use the binomial distribution to find , and describe the shape of the true distribution of .
Step 1: Mean and standard deviation
and .
Step 2: Apply the normal model
Step 3: Explain why this is a problem
A proportion can't be negative, so the true probability is 0. The normal model puts about 11 % of its probability on impossible values. The rule of thumb predicts this: , far below 10.
Step 4: Use the exact distribution
and .
Step 5: Describe the shape
About 22 % of samples have no faulty globes at all, and the distribution of is piled up at with a long right tail. It is strongly skewed to the right, not symmetric and bell-shaped.
Answer
(a) , . (b) The normal model gives , but negative proportions are impossible, so the model is poor; is far too small. (c) ; the true distribution is strongly right-skewed.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Check and before trusting the normal model.
A positive probability for an impossible value is a sign that the model doesn't fit.
When is small, use the binomial distribution.
Watch out for
Reporting 0.107 as the probability of a negative proportion without questioning it.
Thinking the mean and SD formulas fail too: they are exact. Only normality fails.