Lesson 6: The normal approximation for p̂
Is the sample consistent with the claim?
SkillsNormal approximation for p̂Simulation and standardising
Worked example
An electricity retailer advertises that "80 % of our customers are satisfied with our service". A consumer group surveys a random sample of 400 of the retailer's customers, and 300 say they are satisfied.
Assuming the retailer's claim is true, find the probability of a sample proportion as low as or lower than the one observed. Use your answer to comment on the claim.
Step 1: Calculate the observed proportion
Step 2: Model p̂ assuming the claim
If , then and are large, so with .
Step 3: Standardise the observation
: the sample is 2.5 standard deviations below the claimed value.
Step 4: Find the probability
Step 5: Comment on the claim
If 80 % of customers really were satisfied, only about 6 in every 1000 random samples of 400 would give a proportion this low. The observed result would be very unusual, so the sample is strong evidence that fewer than 80 % of customers are satisfied.
This doesn't prove the claim false — unlikely samples do happen — but it makes the claim hard to believe, provided the survey was genuinely random and unbiased.
Answer
and, if , . A result this low would be very unusual if the claim were true, so the data cast serious doubt on the claim (assuming the sample was random and unbiased).
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Assume the claimed and model with the normal approximation.
Find the probability of a result at least as extreme as the one observed.
A very small probability (say below 0.05) means the observation is unusual under the claim, which casts doubt on it.
Watch out for
Finding , which is 0 for a continuous model. Use a tail probability.
Concluding the claim is definitely false. A small probability is evidence, not proof.