Lesson 7: Using intervals to judge claims
Does the survey support the council's claim?
SkillsJudging claims with intervalsCalculating confidence intervals
Worked example
A city council claims that 70% of residents support a new bikeway. A random sample of 850 residents finds that 561 support it.
(a) Calculate an approximate 95% confidence interval for the proportion of all residents who support the bikeway.
(b) Use your interval to evaluate the council's claim.
Step 1: Find the sample proportion
Step 2: Calculate the margin of error
Step 3: Write the interval
Step 4: Compare the claim with the interval
The claimed value lies above the interval.
Step 5: Conclude in context
The survey gives evidence, at 95% confidence, that support for the bikeway is lower than the council claims: plausibly between 62.8% and 69.2%. Support is still clearly a majority.
Evaluating a claim means saying whether the data support it, and what the data suggest instead.
Answer
(a) . (b) 0.70 is outside (above) the interval, so the data suggest support is lower than 70%, although still a clear majority.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate the interval.
Inside: plausible. Outside: evidence against, in a stated direction.
Conclude in context.
Watch out for
Saying "the claim is proven false": the interval gives evidence, at a stated confidence level, not proof.