Lesson 8: Building optimisation models
The best angle for a rain gutter
SkillsBuilding optimisation modelsThe second derivative test
Worked example
A rain gutter is made from a strip of metal 30 cm wide by bending up 10 cm on each side. The base is 10 cm wide and each side makes an angle with the horizontal, where , so the cross-section is a trapezium with positive top width.
(a) Show that the area of the cross-section is cm².
(b) Determine the angle that lets the gutter carry the most water, and the maximum cross-sectional area.
Step 1: (a) Find the height and the top width
Each slanted side is 10 cm at angle , so the height is and each side reaches beyond the base horizontally. The top width is .
Step 2: Use the trapezium area formula
Step 3: (b) Differentiate
Expand first: . Using the product rule on the second term,
Step 4: Write in terms of cos θ and factorise
With ,
Writing everything in terms of turns the equation into a quadratic in .
Step 5: Solve dA/dθ = 0 in the domain
gives . gives , outside the domain (the gutter would be flat and folded back).
Step 6: Justify the maximum
At : , so this is a maximum.
Step 7: Find the maximum area
cm²
Answer
The gutter carries the most water when (60°), giving a maximum cross-sectional area of cm².
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Use trigonometry to write the lengths in terms of the angle.
Differentiate, then use to get a quadratic in .
Keep solutions in the domain and justify with the second derivative.
Watch out for
Working in degrees. Calculus with trigonometric functions needs radians.
Assuming the best angle is (vertical sides). Sloping the sides outwards widens the top, which helps until .