Lesson 8: Modelling with binomial distributions
Seedling punnets, a two-stage binomial model
SkillsModelling with binomial distributionsBinomial probabilitiesRecognising binomial situations
Worked example
A nursery sells punnets of 10 seedlings. Each seedling fails to grow with probability 0.05, independently of the others. A customer is happy with a punnet if at most one of its seedlings fails.
(a) Determine the probability that a customer is happy with a punnet, correct to 4 decimal places.
(b) A café buys 8 punnets. Determine the probability that the café is happy with at least 7 of them, correct to 4 decimal places.
(c) State one assumption needed in (b) and explain whether it is reasonable.
Step 1: Model one punnet
Let be the number of failed seedlings in a punnet: .
Step 2: Find the probability of a happy punnet
Step 3: Model the 8 punnets
Let be the number of happy punnets: with (kept unrounded in the calculator).
Each punnet is now a Bernoulli trial whose "success" is "happy", with the probability from part (a).
Step 4: Find "at least 7"
Step 5: Evaluate an assumption
The model assumes punnets are independent with the same . Punnets from the same batch share soil, seed stock and watering, so failures may cluster and may differ between batches. If so, the true probability could be lower than 0.8533.
Answer
(a) . (b) . (c) Punnets are assumed independent with the same probability of being satisfactory; this is doubtful if they come from one batch, because failures could cluster.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Solve the inner problem: a probability for one group.
Use that probability as in a second binomial model for the number of groups.
Keep unrounded values in the calculator between stages.
Evaluate independence and constant in context.
Watch out for
Using 0.95 as the probability that a punnet is satisfactory.
Rounding to 0.91 before the second stage.
Calculating only for "at least 7".