Lesson 7: Loan repayments, total interest and choosing a loan
25 years or 30 years?
SkillsRepayments and total interestComparing loans and investments
Worked example
Chloe is borrowing $480 000 at 6.24% p.a. compounded monthly. Her broker shows her a 30-year loan and a 25-year loan. Chloe says, "The 30-year loan is better because the repayments are lower."
Evaluate Chloe's claim. Include the monthly repayment and the total interest for each loan.
Step 1: Repayment on the 25-year loan
, : , so .
Step 2: Repayment on the 30-year loan
: , so .
Step 3: Total interest on each
25 years:
30 years:
Step 4: Compare
The 30-year loan costs less each month, but more in interest.
Step 5: Evaluate the claim
Chloe is right that the 30-year repayments are lower, but "better" depends on her budget. If she can afford the extra $211.13 a month, the 25-year loan saves over $113 000 and is paid off 5 years sooner. The 30-year loan only makes sense if the lower repayment is what makes the loan affordable — and she could still make extra repayments when she is able to.
An evaluation weighs the evidence for both sides and reaches a justified decision.
Step 6: State the assumptions
This assumes the rate stays at 6.24% for the whole term and ignores fees. Most Australian home loans have variable rates, so the real figures will differ.
Answer
Chloe's claim is only partly true. The 30-year loan's repayment is $211.13 a month lower ($2952.32 against $3163.45), but it costs $113 800.20 more in interest. If she can afford the higher repayment, the 25-year loan is the better choice.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Calculate the repayment for each option.
Calculate the total interest for each option.
Compare both the monthly cost and the total cost.
Make a decision that refers to the numbers, and state the assumptions.
Watch out for
Comparing only the repayments, or only the total interest. An evaluation needs both.
Thinking the 30-year loan costs 5 years more of repayments only. The extra interest is much larger, because the balance stays high for longer.