Lesson 7: Solving problems with bivariate data
Evaluate a claim of cause
SkillsSolving bivariate problemsAssociation and causationNon-causal explanations
Worked example
For 12 regional Queensland towns, a council report plots the number of fast-food outlets per 10 000 people against the hospital admissions for heart disease per 10 000 people. It finds and concludes: "Limiting the number of fast-food outlets will reduce heart disease in our town." Evaluate this conclusion.
Step 1: Describe the association
shows a strong positive linear association: towns with more fast-food outlets per person tend to have more heart-disease admissions per person.
Step 2: Quantify it
, so about 67% of the variation in admission rates can be explained by the variation in fast-food outlet numbers. About a third is due to other factors.
Step 3: Association is not causation
The data is observational — the council didn't change the number of outlets and watch what happened — so it shows association only.
Step 4: Suggest confounding variables
Towns with an older population, lower average income or higher smoking rates may have both more fast-food outlets and more heart disease. Any of these could produce the association.
Step 5: Consider the data
Twelve towns is a small sample, so the association may also partly be chance.
Step 6: Conclude
The data supports an association but not the claim that limiting outlets will reduce heart disease. To test the claim you would need to control for the other variables or run a controlled study.
Answer
The conclusion is not justified. There is a strong positive association (, ), but the data is observational; age, income and smoking rates could cause both variables, and 12 towns is a small sample. Limiting outlets may not reduce heart disease.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe and quantify the association.
Say what kind of data it is: observational data shows association, not cause.
Name specific confounding variables and how they link to both.
Reach a clear conclusion about the claim.
Watch out for
Agreeing with the claim because is large.
Rejecting the claim without giving a specific alternative explanation.