Lesson 7: Solving problems with bivariate data

Evaluate a claim of cause

SkillsSolving bivariate problemsAssociation and causationNon-causal explanations

Worked example

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology active

For 12 regional Queensland towns, a council report plots the number of fast-food outlets per 10 000 people against the hospital admissions for heart disease per 10 000 people. It finds r=0.82r = 0.82 and concludes: "Limiting the number of fast-food outlets will reduce heart disease in our town." Evaluate this conclusion.

1 of 6 steps
  1. Step 1: Describe the association

    r=0.82r = 0.82 shows a strong positive linear association: towns with more fast-food outlets per person tend to have more heart-disease admissions per person.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Describe and quantify the association.

  2. Say what kind of data it is: observational data shows association, not cause.

  3. Name specific confounding variables and how they link to both.

  4. Reach a clear conclusion about the claim.

Watch out for

  • Agreeing with the claim because rr is large.

  • Rejecting the claim without giving a specific alternative explanation.

Save your progress with a free account