Lesson 4: Describing associations in two-way tables
Evaluate a claim built on counts
SkillsAssociations in two-way tablesPercentaging two-way tables
Worked example
A Townsville café owner recorded the milk chosen by 450 customers who ordered a coffee.
| Age group | Oat milk | Other milk or none | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 35 | 84 | 216 | 300 |
| 35 and over | 63 | 87 | 150 |
| Total | 147 | 303 | 450 |
The owner claims: "Younger customers are more likely to choose oat milk — 84 of them ordered it, compared with only 63 older customers." Evaluate the owner's claim.
Step 1: Identify what the claim is based on
The claim compares counts (84 and 63). The age groups are different sizes — 300 customers under 35 and only 150 aged 35 and over — so the counts can't be compared fairly.
A group twice the size will tend to have bigger counts in every column, whatever its preferences.
Step 2: Calculate percentages within each age group
Under 35: chose oat milk.
35 and over: chose oat milk.
Step 3: Compare
Customers aged 35 and over were more likely to choose oat milk (42% compared with 28%). The data suggests an association between age group and choosing oat milk — in the opposite direction to the claim.
Step 4: Evaluate the claim
The claim is not supported. It rests on counts, and younger customers placed more oat milk orders only because there were twice as many younger customers. The percentages show that older customers are more likely to choose oat milk.
The data also comes from one café's customers, so the pattern may not hold for other cafés.
"Evaluate" asks for a judgement with reasons: say whether the claim is reasonable, show the evidence, and note any limitation of the data.
Answer
The claim is not supported: 42% of customers aged 35 and over chose oat milk, compared with only 28% of those under 35. Younger customers placed more oat milk orders only because there were twice as many of them.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Check whether the claim uses counts or percentages, and whether the groups are the same size.
Calculate percentages within each category of the explanatory variable.
Decide whether the percentages support the claim, and say why.
Mention any limitation of the data, such as where the sample came from.
Watch out for
Agreeing with the claim because 84 is bigger than 63.
Percentaging down the oat milk column (), which only shows that most oat milk orders came from the bigger group.