Lesson 8: Choosing statistics and knowing their limits
Is the advertised "average rent" fair?
SkillsChoosing summary statisticsRange and interquartile range
Worked example
A real estate agent's flyer says "Average weekly rent for two-bedroom units in this Townsville street: $471". The weekly rents of the 10 two-bedroom units in the street are:
$380, $395, $400, $410, $420, $420, $430, $445, $460, $950
The $950 unit is a renovated beachfront apartment. Evaluate the flyer's claim, and recommend the statistics the agent should report for the centre and spread of these rents.
Step 1: Check the claim
. The flyer has calculated the mean correctly.
Step 2: Look at the shape
Nine rents lie between $380 and $460. The $950 rent stands far above the rest: a possible outlier that makes the distribution positively skewed.
Step 3: Find the resistant statistics
The rents are in order with , so the median is the mean of the 5th and 6th rents: .
The lower half 380, 395, 400, 410, 420 gives , and the upper half 420, 430, 445, 460, 950 gives . So .
Step 4: Compare with the sensitive statistics
With technology, , and the range is $570. Both are inflated by the $950 rent. Without that rent the mean would be about $417.78, while the median would stay at $420.
A statistic that changes a lot when one value is removed is being driven by that value.
Step 5: Evaluate and recommend
The claim is accurate but misleading: 9 of the 10 rents are below $471, so the mean overstates a typical rent. The agent should report the median ($420) and the IQR ($45), which are resistant to the outlier, and could mention the beachfront unit separately.
Answer
The mean of $471 is correct but misleading, because one $950 rent skews the data and 9 of the 10 rents are lower. The agent should report the median, $420, and the IQR, $45.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Check the claimed statistic.
Look at the shape and any outliers.
Calculate the resistant statistics (median and IQR) and compare them with the sensitive ones.
Make a judgement, justify it with values from the data, and recommend.
Watch out for
Saying the claim is false. The mean is calculated correctly; it is the choice of statistic that misleads.
Recommending the mean and standard deviation for skewed data with an outlier.