Lesson 8: Step graphs
Step charge or per-kilogram charge?
SkillsStep graphsComparing two options
Worked example
A small online business in Mackay posts parcels of up to 5 kg. Two couriers quote:
- ParcelPoint (by weight band): up to 0.5 kg $9.50; over 0.5 kg up to 1 kg $13.00; over 1 kg up to 3 kg $17.50; over 3 kg up to 5 kg $22.00.
- ZipFreight: $6.00 plus $3.50 per kilogram of the parcel's exact weight.
For which parcel weights is ParcelPoint cheaper? Justify your answer.
Step 1: Model ZipFreight
for a parcel of kg — a straight line.
Step 2: Compare band by band, using the heaviest parcel in each band
ZipFreight's charge is highest at the top of each band, so check there:
- :
- :
- :
So ZipFreight is cheaper for every weight up to 3 kg.
Within a band ParcelPoint's charge is constant and ZipFreight's rises, so if ZipFreight is cheaper at the top of a band it is cheaper across the whole band.
Step 3: Find where they are equal in the last band
For , ParcelPoint charges $22: kg.
Step 4: Decide
Above 4.57 kg, ZipFreight's line is above $22, so ParcelPoint is cheaper. Check: at 5 kg ZipFreight charges ✓.
Answer
ParcelPoint is cheaper only for parcels heavier than about 4.57 kg (up to 5 kg). For every lighter parcel, ZipFreight is cheaper, because its line lies below every ParcelPoint step up to 3 kg and below $22 until kg.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Model the smooth option as a line and the banded option as a step graph.
Compare at the critical points — the ends of each band.
Where the line crosses a step, solve for the changeover value.
State the decision for every interval of weights, with evidence.
Watch out for
Comparing at a single weight and generalising. The answer changes from band to band, so check each one.
Comparing at the bottom of each band only. ZipFreight's charge is highest at the top of each band.