Lesson 5: Break-even analysis
Should a candle maker take a market stall?
SkillsBreak-even analysisComparing two options
Worked example
Aroha makes soy candles in Toowoomba and sells them online for $24 each. Her fixed costs are $2400 a month, and each candle costs $9.50 in wax, wick, jar and postage. She expects to sell 220 candles a month.
A weekend market stall would add $350 a month to her fixed costs, but she expects it to lift her sales to 300 candles a month (her price and cost per candle stay the same).
Evaluate whether Aroha should take the market stall. Include her current and new break-even points in your answer.
Step 1: Find the contribution per candle
Each candle contributes towards fixed costs and profit.
Profit is , so the contribution appears in every calculation that follows.
Step 2: Current break-even and profit
Break-even: , so she must sell 166 candles a month.
Profit at 220 candles: a month.
At 165 candles she would still make a small loss, so round up.
Step 3: Break-even and profit with the stall
Fixed costs become .
Break-even: , so 190 candles a month.
Profit at 300 candles: a month.
Step 4: Find the extra sales needed to justify the stall
The stall costs $350 more, so it pays for itself if it brings at least , that is 25 extra candles a month.
This shows how much room for error there is in her sales estimate.
Step 5: Evaluate
With the stall, profit roughly doubles ($1600 against $790), and the stall only needs 25 extra sales a month to pay for itself, while she expects 80. The break-even point rises from 166 to 190 candles, but her expected sales are well above both.
Answer
Aroha should take the stall, provided her sales estimate is realistic. Her break-even point rises from 166 to 190 candles a month, but her expected profit rises from $790 to $1600 a month. The stall pays for itself with just 25 extra sales a month, so even if sales lift by much less than the expected 80 candles, she is still better off. A limitation is that the 300-candle estimate is uncertain and her time at the market is not costed.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Find the contribution per item, .
Find the break-even point and the expected profit under each option.
Find what the change needs to achieve to pay for itself.
Make a decision, back it with your figures and state an assumption or limitation.
Watch out for
Rounding the break-even number down (165 or 189). Round up: she needs a whole number of candles to cover her costs.
Comparing break-even points only. A higher break-even point can still come with a higher profit.