Lesson 3: Commission, piecework and income support
Which job: an hourly wage or a retainer plus commission?
SkillsCommission and pieceworkWages, salaries and overtime
Worked example
Ella has been offered two sales jobs.
- Job A pays $29.50 an hour for a 38-hour week.
- Job B pays a retainer of $380 a week plus 6% commission on her sales.
In a similar job over the last 8 weeks, Ella's weekly sales ranged from $9800 to $15 400, with a mean of $12 900. Which job should she take? Justify your answer.
Step 1: Weekly pay in Job A
Step 2: Job B at her mean sales
Using the mean gives a typical week, but Job B's pay changes with sales, so one figure is not enough.
Step 3: Find the break-even sales
Job B pays the same as Job A when the commission is . Sales .
Above $12 350 of sales Job B pays more; below it, Job A pays more.
Step 4: Test the lowest and highest weeks
Lowest: , which is $153 less than Job A. Highest: , which is $183 more.
Step 5: Decide and justify
On her mean sales Job B pays $33 a week more (about a year). But her mean is only $550 above the break-even, and in a slow week she would earn $153 less than in Job A. If Ella expects her sales to stay near $12 900 or grow, Job B is the better choice. If she needs a steady, predictable income, for rent or a loan, Job A is safer.
Answer
Job B pays more on average ($1154 against $1121 a week), but only in weeks when sales are above $12 350, and her pay would swing between about $968 and $1304. Job B suits Ella if her sales stay near or above $12 900; Job A suits her if she needs a reliable income.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Put both options in the same period.
Work out the sales-based option at typical, low and high sales.
Find the break-even sales, where both options pay the same.
Decide using the figures, and comment on the risk.
Watch out for
Deciding from the mean alone. A strong answer also comments on how much the pay varies and how close the mean is to the break-even.