Lesson 4: Finding an unknown pronumeral
When do Young's and Clark's rules agree?
SkillsSubstituting into non-linear formulasFinding an unknown pronumeral
Worked example
The adult dose of a medicine is 500 mg. Sam is 8 years old and has a mass of 25 kg.
(a) Calculate Sam's dose using Young's rule, .
(b) Calculate Sam's dose using Clark's rule, , correct to one decimal place.
(c) A younger child also has a mass of 25 kg. At what age would Young's rule give this child the same dose as Clark's rule?
(d) Explain why a rule based on mass may be more appropriate for children who are large or small for their age.
Step 1: (a) Substitute into Young's rule
mg
Step 2: (b) Substitute into Clark's rule
mg
Step 3: (c) Set the two fractions equal
The adult dose is the same in both rules, so the doses are equal when the fractions are equal:
Both doses are a fraction of the same 500 mg, so the 500 cancels.
Step 4: Clear the fractions
Multiply both sides by :
Step 5: Collect the unknown and solve
, so years (6 years 8 months)
Step 6: (d) Explain
Young's rule assumes every child of a given age is a typical size. Clark's rule uses the child's actual mass, which better reflects how much medicine their body needs, so it adjusts for children who are much heavier or lighter than average for their age.
Answer
(a) 200 mg (b) 178.6 mg (c) about 6.7 years (6 years 8 months) (d) Mass-based doses adjust for a child's actual size, which age-based rules ignore.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Substitute into each rule separately.
To find when two rules agree, set the expressions equal.
Clear fractions by multiplying both sides by the denominators, then solve.
Watch out for
Writing . A fraction cannot be split over a sum in its denominator.
Multiplying only the left side by .