Lesson 5: Analysing and evaluating fiscal policy
Evaluate a proposed fiscal stimulus using unseen data
SkillsEvaluating fiscal policyPolicy on the AD–AS diagram
Worked example
Illustrative economy. The table gives indicators for the last two years.
| Indicator | Last year | This year |
|---|---|---|
| Real GDP growth | 2.2% | 0.4% |
| Unemployment rate | 4.3% | 5.6% |
| Trimmed mean inflation | 2.6% | 1.7% |
| Cash rate target | 1.00% | 0.25% |
| Underlying cash balance | −0.5% of GDP | −1.6% of GDP |
The government proposes $25 billion of spending over two years on road and rail projects, plus one-off payments to low-income households. Evaluate the likely effectiveness of this fiscal response in achieving the economy's objectives.
Step 1: Diagnose the economy
Growth has slowed sharply, unemployment has risen 1.3 percentage points and inflation is below the 2–3% band: a contraction with a recessionary gap and cyclical unemployment. The budget has moved further into deficit, partly through the automatic stabilisers.
Step 2: Explain how the stimulus works
The one-off payments go to households likely to spend most of them, raising C quickly; the projects raise G. AD shifts right, multiplied as incomes are re-spent, closing part of the gap, raising employment and lifting inflation back towards target. Draw AD → AD₁ with real GDP rising towards full employment.
Step 3: Weigh the timing
The payments can reach households within weeks, a strength. Road and rail projects need planning and approvals, so much of the spending may come in the second year or later, possibly once the economy is recovering.
Step 4: Weigh the role of monetary policy
The cash rate is already 0.25%, close to its lower bound, so monetary policy has little room left. That makes fiscal stimulus more necessary and more effective (there is little risk of interest rates rising to crowd out private investment).
Step 5: Weigh sustainability and the long run
Spending adds to a deficit already at 1.6% of GDP and to public debt. But infrastructure also raises productive capacity (LRAS) over time, so part of the debt funds future growth, unlike pure transfers.
Step 6: Judge
Largely effective. The payments act quickly where they are needed, and with monetary policy near its limit fiscal policy is the main tool. Its effectiveness depends on getting the infrastructure under way quickly and on withdrawing the stimulus as the recovery comes, to limit debt and inflation risk.
Answer
Largely effective: it targets a clear recessionary gap with low inflation while monetary policy is near its lower bound; the payments act quickly and the infrastructure adds to capacity. Limits: implementation lags on projects, higher debt from an existing deficit, and a risk of adding to demand late in the recovery.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Diagnose the economy from the data: phase, gap, objectives missed.
Explain the mechanism: components of AD, multiplier, diagram.
Weigh criteria: timing, targeting, monetary policy's position, sustainability, long-run effects.
Reach and justify a judgement.
Watch out for
Describing the stimulus without using the data in the table.
Ignoring that monetary policy is near its lower bound, a key point for the judgement.