Lesson 5: Analysing and evaluating fiscal policy

Evaluate a proposed fiscal stimulus using unseen data

SkillsEvaluating fiscal policyPolicy on the AD–AS diagram

Worked example

  • Complex unfamiliar

Illustrative economy. The table gives indicators for the last two years.

IndicatorLast yearThis year
Real GDP growth2.2%0.4%
Unemployment rate4.3%5.6%
Trimmed mean inflation2.6%1.7%
Cash rate target1.00%0.25%
Underlying cash balance−0.5% of GDP−1.6% of GDP

The government proposes $25 billion of spending over two years on road and rail projects, plus one-off payments to low-income households. Evaluate the likely effectiveness of this fiscal response in achieving the economy's objectives.

1 of 6 steps
  1. Step 1: Diagnose the economy

    Growth has slowed sharply, unemployment has risen 1.3 percentage points and inflation is below the 2–3% band: a contraction with a recessionary gap and cyclical unemployment. The budget has moved further into deficit, partly through the automatic stabilisers.

Try a similar one

A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.

Method

  1. Diagnose the economy from the data: phase, gap, objectives missed.

  2. Explain the mechanism: components of AD, multiplier, diagram.

  3. Weigh criteria: timing, targeting, monetary policy's position, sustainability, long-run effects.

  4. Reach and justify a judgement.

Watch out for

  • Describing the stimulus without using the data in the table.

  • Ignoring that monetary policy is near its lower bound, a key point for the judgement.

Save your progress with a free account