Lesson 2: What drives globalisation, and the WTO, IMF and World Bank
Technology or policy: what drove Australia's trade with Asia?
SkillsDrivers of globalisationThe WTO, IMF and World Bank
Worked example
Evaluate the relative importance of technology and government policy in the growth of Australia's trade with Asia since the 1980s.
Step 1: Set the criterion for "importance"
Judge each factor by how much of the growth would not have happened without it.
An evaluation needs a criterion; without one, "more important" is just an opinion.
Step 2: Make the case for technology
Bulk carriers, containers and cheaper air freight cut the cost of moving iron ore, coal, LNG and food to Asia, and the internet made education and tourism services easy to sell. Without low transport costs, low-value bulk resources could not be traded over thousands of kilometres at a profit.
Step 3: Make the case for policy
Australia's tariff cuts (from 1973 and the late 1980s) moved resources into mining and agriculture, its comparative advantage. The 1983 float and financial deregulation let foreign capital finance new mines. GATT and WTO rules, and agreements such as ChAFTA (2015), lowered the barriers Asian countries set against Australian goods.
Step 4: Weigh them
Technology was necessary but not sufficient: containers existed in the 1970s, when Australia still protected manufacturing and Asian markets were closed. Policy decided how much of the potential was used, and the direction: China's own opening and growth, a policy choice, created the demand.
Step 5: Decide, with a condition
On balance, policy (in Australia and in Asia) explains more of the growth since the 1980s, with technology as the precondition. The judgement is weaker for services such as online education, where digital technology was itself the breakthrough.
Answer
Technology set the potential by making long-distance trade cheap; policy choices (Australian liberalisation and deregulation, WTO rules, Asian opening and FTAs) decided how much of it was realised, so policy explains more of the growth since the 1980s, except for digitally traded services.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
State a criterion for "importance".
Make the strongest case for each factor with evidence.
Weigh them against each other; decide; give the condition.