Lesson 9: Total revenue and why elasticity matters
Why governments tax tobacco
SkillsTotal revenue and why elasticity mattersPrice elasticity of demand
Worked example
Australian governments have raised the tobacco excise many times since 2010. The World Bank's widely cited estimate of the price elasticity of demand for cigarettes in high-income countries such as Australia is about 0.4.
Analyse the significance of this elasticity for (a) the government, (b) smokers and (c) tobacco retailers.
Step 1: Interpret the number
A PED of about 0.4 means a 10% rise in price cuts the quantity demanded by about 4%: demand is inelastic, because nicotine is addictive and smokers see few substitutes.
Step 2: (a) The government
Because quantity falls by a smaller percentage than the price rises, an excise raises substantial revenue without wiping out the tax base. But the same inelasticity means each increase reduces smoking only modestly, so health goals need large and repeated rises, plus other measures (plain packaging, education, quit support).
Step 3: (b) Smokers
With inelastic demand, smokers bear most of each rise and spend more in total. Smokers on low incomes spend a larger share of their income on tobacco, so the excise falls hardest on them (it is regressive). Over a longer time demand becomes more elastic, as more people quit.
Step 4: (c) Retailers
Retailers sell fewer packets, but the excise goes to the government, so their margin depends on the quantity sold. Higher prices also encourage illegal tobacco, which takes sales from legal retailers.
Answer
Inelastic demand (about 0.4) lets the government raise large revenue while reducing smoking only gradually; smokers, especially those on low incomes, bear most of the tax; retailers lose volume and face competition from illegal tobacco.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Interpret the PED value in words.
For each group, say how inelastic demand shapes the outcome.
Add the long-run view and any trade-offs.
Watch out for
Saying a tax on an inelastic good will "stop people smoking". Inelastic demand means quantity falls only a little.