Lesson 10: Carrying capacity and climatic events
Nutrients and the carrying capacity of duckweed
SkillCarrying capacity
Worked example
Students grew duckweed (Lemna) in beakers of pond water with a low or high concentration of a nutrient solution, with three beakers per treatment, all on the same bench under the same lights. They counted fronds every three days. The table gives the mean count.
| Day | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low nutrient | |||||||||
| High nutrient |
(a) Identify the independent and dependent variables. (b) Estimate the carrying capacity of a beaker in each treatment. (c) Explain the difference. (d) Name two variables that should be controlled, and one way to improve the reliability of the results.
Step 1: Variables
Independent: nutrient concentration (low or high). Dependent: the number of fronds.
Step 2: Estimate each carrying capacity
The counts level off at about fronds (low) and about fronds (high), so these are the carrying capacities.
Carrying capacity is the plateau of a logistic curve, not the highest single count or the fastest growth.
Step 3: Explain the difference
Nutrients such as nitrate and phosphate are needed to make proteins, nucleic acids and chlorophyll. In the low-nutrient beakers they run out first and limit growth at a lower population. With more nutrients, growth continues until another factor, such as space on the water surface or light, becomes limiting, so is higher.
Step 4: Controlled variables and reliability
Controlled: beaker size and water volume (surface area), light intensity and duration, temperature, starting number of fronds. Reliability: use more replicate beakers (say five per treatment) and repeat the experiment, checking that counts agree.
Answer
(a) IV: nutrient concentration; DV: frond number. (b) About 80 (low) and 180 (high). (c) Nutrients limit growth at the low concentration; with more, another factor (surface area, light) limits it at a higher level. (d) For example, surface area and light; more replicates.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Carrying capacity is where the curve plateaus.
Explain a change in K by naming the limiting factor and what the organisms use it for.
Watch out for
Giving the last count as K without checking it has levelled off.
Saying "repeat the experiment" makes it more accurate (it improves reliability).