Lesson 1: Homeostasis and negative feedback
Explain the control of breathing as negative feedback
SkillsHomeostasis and negative feedbackReading feedback-control diagrams
Worked example
During a run, a student's muscles produce more carbon dioxide, and the concentration of carbon dioxide in the blood rises. Chemoreceptors in the medulla of the brain and in the carotid and aortic bodies detect the rise and send impulses to the respiratory centre in the medulla. The respiratory centre sends impulses to the diaphragm and intercostal muscles, which contract faster and more strongly.
Explain why this is an example of negative feedback, identifying each part of the stimulus-response model.
Step 1: Name the stimulus
The stimulus is the rise in blood carbon dioxide concentration (which also lowers blood pH).
Step 2: Name the receptors and the control centre
The receptors are the chemoreceptors in the medulla and in the carotid and aortic bodies. The control centre is the respiratory centre in the medulla.
Step 3: Name the pathways and effectors
Impulses travel along sensory neurons to the respiratory centre, and along motor neurons to the effectors, the diaphragm and intercostal muscles.
Step 4: State the response
The muscles contract faster and more strongly, so breathing becomes faster and deeper and more carbon dioxide is exhaled.
Step 5: Explain why it is negative feedback
The response lowers blood carbon dioxide, the opposite of the original change. As the concentration returns towards normal, the chemoreceptors fire less and breathing slows again.
Negative feedback is defined by the direction of the response relative to the stimulus, so this is the step that answers the question.
Answer
A rise in blood (stimulus) is detected by chemoreceptors (receptors), which signal along sensory neurons to the respiratory centre (control centre); motor neurons stimulate the diaphragm and intercostal muscles (effectors) to breathe faster and deeper (response). This lowers blood , reversing the stimulus: negative feedback.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Name the stimulus as a change with a direction.
Identify receptors, control centre, pathways and effectors in order.
State the response and show that it reverses the stimulus.
Watch out for
Calling the lungs the effector. The lungs do not contract; the diaphragm and intercostal muscles do.
Stopping at "breathing gets faster" without saying that this lowers carbon dioxide, the point of negative feedback.