Lesson 6: Photosynthesis in the chloroplast
Tracing the oxygen in photosynthesis with a heavy isotope
SkillStages of photosynthesis
Worked example
In 1941 Samuel Ruben, Martin Kamen and colleagues grew the alga Chlorella with water or carbon dioxide enriched with the heavy isotope oxygen-18, and measured the percentage of oxygen-18 in the oxygen gas released. Results like theirs are shown. (The natural abundance of oxygen-18 is about 0.20 %.)
| Experiment | % ¹⁸O in water | % ¹⁸O in CO₂ | % ¹⁸O in O₂ released |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 0.85 | 0.20 | 0.85 |
| 2 | 0.20 | 0.68 | 0.20 |
(a) State what the results show about the source of the oxygen released. (b) Explain which stage of photosynthesis this supports. (c) The syllabus's equation is + light energy . Explain why some textbooks write instead.
Step 1: Read experiment 1
When only the water was enriched, the oxygen released had the same oxygen-18 content as the water (0.85 %).
Step 2: Read experiment 2
When only the carbon dioxide was enriched, the oxygen released had the natural abundance (0.20 %), the same as the water, not the carbon dioxide.
Step 3: Conclude
The oxygen released comes from water, not from carbon dioxide.
In each experiment the released oxygen matches the water, whichever compound was labelled.
Step 4: Link to the stage
This supports photolysis in the light-dependent reactions: water is split on the thylakoid membranes, , releasing its oxygen as .
Step 5: Count the oxygen atoms
contains 12 oxygen atoms. If all of them come from water, 12 water molecules must be split. The carbon dioxide's oxygen atoms go into glucose and into 6 new water molecules made in the Calvin cycle. Both equations are balanced; the second shows where the atoms go, and cancelling 6 H₂O from each side gives the first.
Answer
(a) The oxygen released comes from water. (b) Photolysis of water in the light-dependent reactions. (c) Twelve water molecules must be split to supply the 12 oxygen atoms in 6 O₂; 6 water molecules are re-formed in the light-independent reactions.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare the labelled product with each labelled input: the one it matches is its source.
Count atoms on each side to check an equation.
Watch out for
Concluding the oxygen comes from carbon dioxide because carbon dioxide has two oxygen atoms.
Thinking the 12 H₂O equation is unbalanced. It is balanced; it just does not cancel the water.