Lesson 1: Prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells
Compare a bacterium with a human liver cell
SkillProkaryotic and eukaryotic cells
Worked example
Escherichia coli is a bacterium that lives in the human large intestine. Compare the structure of an E. coli cell with that of a human liver cell. Include at least one similarity and three differences.
Step 1: Classify each cell
E. coli is a bacterium, so it is prokaryotic. A liver cell is a human (animal) cell, so it is eukaryotic.
Classifying first tells you which set of features to compare.
Step 2: State the similarities
Both cells have a cell membrane, cytoplasm, DNA and ribosomes, and both make proteins in the same way.
Step 3: Pair the difference in DNA
E. coli's DNA is a single circular chromosome lying in the nucleoid, with plasmids, whereas the liver cell's DNA is in linear chromosomes inside a nucleus bounded by a double membrane.
Step 4: Pair the difference in organelles and ribosomes
E. coli has no membrane-bound organelles and smaller (70S) ribosomes, whereas the liver cell has mitochondria, rough and smooth ER, a Golgi apparatus and lysosomes, and larger (80S) ribosomes in its cytoplasm.
Step 5: Pair the differences in wall and size
E. coli has a peptidoglycan cell wall outside its membrane, whereas the liver cell has no cell wall. E. coli is about 2 µm long, whereas a liver cell is about 20–30 µm across, ten or more times larger.
Answer
Both have a cell membrane, cytoplasm, DNA and ribosomes. E. coli (prokaryotic) has circular DNA in a nucleoid, no membrane-bound organelles, 70S ribosomes, a peptidoglycan wall and a length of about 2 µm, whereas the liver cell (eukaryotic) has linear chromosomes in a nucleus, membrane-bound organelles, 80S ribosomes, no cell wall and is about 20–30 µm across.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Classify each cell as prokaryotic or eukaryotic (and plant or animal).
State at least one similarity.
Pair each difference in one sentence with whereas: DNA, organelles, ribosomes, wall, size.
Watch out for
Writing two separate descriptions instead of paired comparisons.
Saying the bacterium has no DNA or no ribosomes.