Lesson 5: Cells, tissues, organs and body systems
Apply the 3Rs to a research proposal
SkillLevels of organisation
Worked example
A research team plans to test a new drug for heart disease. Classify each change made by its animal ethics committee as replacement, reduction or refinement.
(a) Test the drug first on heart tissue grown from human stem cells. (b) Give mice pain relief after surgery and house them in groups with nesting material. (c) Use a statistician to calculate the smallest number of mice that will give a reliable result. (d) Image each mouse's heart repeatedly with ultrasound instead of killing groups of mice at each time point.
Step 1: (a) Human heart tissue
Using tissue grown in the laboratory avoids using animals for that part of the work: replacement.
Step 2: (b) Pain relief and housing
This lowers pain and distress and improves the animals' welfare: refinement.
Step 3: (c) Statistical design
Using the fewest animals that still give a valid answer: reduction.
Step 4: (d) Repeated imaging
Following the same animals over time means fewer animals are needed: reduction. (It is also a refinement, because it is less invasive than surgery.)
Some measures serve two of the Rs; name the main one and mention the other.
Answer
(a) Replacement. (b) Refinement. (c) Reduction. (d) Reduction (and refinement).
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Replacement: avoid or replace animals. Reduction: fewer animals. Refinement: less suffering, better welfare.
Watch out for
Calling pain relief "reduction": it reduces pain, but the R is refinement.